Board Thread:Questions and Answers/@comment-26090671-20160919083446/@comment-26371840-20161113125710

Mabian wrote: Hypercosmic wrote: * The point is to decide whether Chara stay with Frisk (as a ghost/narrator) and their memory got erased, too, or not. Just that.No, the question was and is "who is the 'someone else' being referred to during the Asriel battle." While the theory that it is Chara relies on the axiom that Chara is the narrator, the theory that Chara is the narrator does not have to be disproven to show that Chara is not that "someone else."* Also, to further prove that Chara is the narrator, that cutscene that plays after you SAVE 'someone else'. It cannot be from Frisk, obviously, so it has to be Chara.Which is completely meaningless. The cutscene shows Asriel's memory. The cutscene itself does not prove who the "someone else" is. The question of who is being saved is essentially between Asriel and Chara, not Chara and Frisk. No one is suggesting that Frisk is the "someone else" being saved.* If you are asking if Chara's memory can be removed, ask Asriel himself.This makes no sense, since it is in fact impossible to ask Asriel any questions, him being a video game character.* In the end, if Chara is the narrator, which is very likely, then they can be that 'someone else' because thy stayed with Frisk. * This make Undertale storyline making sense.No. As I have gone to great pains to show, that reading does not make sense regardless of whether or not we accept that Chara is the narrator. In fact, everything about the scene suggests that it is supposed to be Asriel who is the "someone else." The fact that only one person is being saved. That the "someone else" prompt immediately changes to Asriel. That Chara (as the narrator) never asks Frisk to save them directly or mentions themself as anything other than some random entity, despite the fact that Chara (as the narrator) has no problem entering themselves more personally into the narration. The Chara as narrator theory is not in question here. But it is not some magical wand that immediately explains everything.* Okay let's just ignore the fight and consider this.

* 'they'.
 * Strangely, as your friends remembered you... Something else began resonating within the SOUL, stronger and stronger. It seems that there's still one last person that needs to be saved. But who...? ... Suddenly, you realize. You reach out and call their name.[Someone else]
 * Strangely, as your friends remembered you... Something else began resonating within the SOUL, stronger and stronger. It seems that there's still one last person that needs to be saved. But who...? ... Suddenly, you realize. You reach out and call their name.[Someone else]

* Frisk would've know Asriel's gender already. It's obvious. Who could it be?

* Chara.