Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-26006155-20181123023529/@comment-32182236-20181128171702

They'd recognize Gaster as a human though, wouldn't they? When he first fell?

Grandpa Semi might be it..? Or, as I suggested, the PREVIOUS king?

Toriel left after Chara's death, so that doesn't count anyways. If you were reaponding to my original argument, it's that it was Asriel.

You did correctly point out that nobody knows what Toriel looks like. Including Sans. So he's not a human.

Far after 201X is indeed my take on the matter as well. At least a generation, I'd say several centuries. 2XXX. Yet, what we see outside appears to be the modern era. That's why their calendar must neccesarily be different than OUR calendar.

..Wait. How do we KNOW that Chara didn't die, say, 2-5 days after they fell? Maybe Asriel did die in 201X after all? The end of it? Due to the hotel existing, we know Chara fell after the move to New Homr occured. (Or, after a partial move:Perhaps Toriel stayed behind in the Ruins with all the monsters who haven't moved yet, keping Asriel there too, and that's how Asriel was able to be around to find Chara, and they all moved then.)

The Waterfall statue plays Asriel's theme, and it may very well have been the original statue, if we presume the puzzle with the legendary artifact was made sometime AFTER 201X. The theme it plays is called "Memory", in fact. Like a memorial theme? Though that would mean a third statue must have existed at one point, because there's no way a puzzle with ancient glyphs as the hint could be only a week old.

Chara, with a red SOUL, almost certainly had S/L/R. So their experience with the nature of SOULs could be across multiple time loops.