Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-35615238-20190121141916/@comment-32182236-20190304184934

I haven't had to deal with spoilers.. But I haven't tried to delve too much into Deltarune either. My reasons differ, however. I'm just trying to solve Undertale first, because we might need that information to later understand Deltarune, and Deltarune simply doesn't have enough information for me to make a clear hypothesis yet. It looks like stuff that was left vague on purpose, because we're not supposed to find out about it until the later chapters come into play.

Really, as long as you stick with the information given in Undertale, and keep with THAT story, you should be fine, and not spoil anything Deltarune-related. If you go through the evidence and find out what happened, but DON'T go into detail about how that information might be revealed in a later installment, it should help reduce the spoilery-aspect.

Let's just say for example that the mystery Kickstarter game has you play as one of the wizards that banished the monsters underground, and your mission is to do some intel on the monsters, and you would eventually witness Gaster and his fall. And let's say you somehow figured all of that out.

Don't go into detail about the wizards gathering intel on Gaster, or even that they're still alive by the time Gaster falls-That has nothing to do with the Undertale story, and could only ever become important when finding out how the humans react to the monsters after the events of the True Pacifist Ending. Just try to find out what he was working on, since that'd probably be revealed pretty early on anyways, and DOES have to do with the story.

Basically, don't use yet-to-be-revealed evidence to support your hypotheses.

As for the Pink Diamond twist, you made it look crazier than it really was. Rose being Pink is not the same as Rose EATING Pink. Pink became Rose (possible because rose quartz and pink diamonds are cut the same way), and it's as simple as that. Perhaps if you start with the smaller sub-theories, and build up to your conclusion, it will work better?

But yes, I suppose that is true-If everything gets definitively solved, the theorizing community will basically die out. There's no reason to look further if the puzzle has already been solved. We'll just be left with speculation of what happens in the future, more Undertale AUs being made.. And that's about it.