Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-39385741-20200106144455

Okay, before you argue and say, "All humans have DT, not just red SOULs", or something like that, let me explain.

Maybe the red SOUL just has a higher concentration than the other SOULs. Enough to SAVE. Now, i know what your thinking. "But Chara has a red SOUL, and they died".

But Chara commited suicide. And when you commit suicide, you don't want to live. Or, you could say, you're not determined to live. And, the only reason Frisk wakes up back at their last SAVE point is because they were determined to live.

Now we have a pretty good theory. But there's still one roadblock left.

This dialogue happens when you reset, die, or reload your SAVE file to before Toriel asks for your preference between butterscotch and cinnimon. And it's a pretty large roadblock.

I've been around this wiki for long enough to see the idea of "Red SOUL is Determination!" thrown around a few times. If they didn't end before, they ended when this quote is thrown in. It suggests that all of the humans that fell into the Underground could SAVE.

But, that leads to a question. All of the humans that fell into the Underground died (Excluding Frisk). So, does that mean they all commited suicide? Seems pretty unlikely. Perhaps the humans just, simply, reminded Toriel of Chara.

Well, that's the end of the theory. Please tell me if I got anything wrong, or if you have something to disprove my theory. That kind of stuff really helps me make my theories. 