Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-26907577-20191002153041/@comment-26907577-20191012140859

What if Frisk wasn't the Determination Wizard...

But Chara was?

Think about it this way: Chara fell down, and had a plan: Get the SOULs of all seven revived wizards to break the barrier after a long time.

But, being a child, Chara had another idea. Which wasn't a particularly good one, but they weren't properly thinking about it.

Do it themselves, with their best friend.

Hence, the Buttercup Incident.

Chara's SOUL was destroyed, and the original plan corrupted forever. It would take another force to fulfill the monsters' prophecy.

The other six wizards fell, picked up on the news, and died hopeful that somebody could fix it.

And then another red human came along. And the Brilliant Doctor Alphys accidentally created somebody to meet them.

Frisk and Flowey were not part of the wizards' plan, but thanks to the efforts of the six obedient wizards, it was fulfilled anyway.

Or Frisk repeats Chara's plan in a much worse way, and convinces a very, very disoriented narrator to go along with it.

This is pretty speculative, but I think it's pretty good. Thoughts?