Board Thread:Questions and Answers/@comment-26242189-20160422234238/@comment-27701762-20160515235122

Arthurtilly wrote:

Mabian wrote: To my recollection, there is no indication that Asgore was actually responsible for their deaths. It is possible that he killed them, but it is also possible that they were killed by other monsters, or that they died in various traps in the Underground. Though my memory has been fading on these lines, so I may just be forgetting something. Actually, I think it's been confirmed that all six humans got to Asgore, but none of them made it past him. Can you point out the info that confirms it? Various lines only vaguely hint at Asgore's strength, and the closest you get to "confirmation" is when Undyne says that no human has gotten past Asgore, which would be a true statement even if Asgore had never killed any of the previous humans. Since Asgore made a proclamation that any human that enters the Underground must die, the other monsters could have killed the previous humans, and Asgore could have simply gone to collect the souls.