Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-26980570-20160320192450/@comment-27701762-20170321213516

David The Potato wrote:Ok..... Lemon Bread is Shryen's Sister. I did not mistake anything. Like Happstablook say's in her diary.  Shyren's sister "fell down" recently. Fell Down? YOU SAID IT RIGHT THERE! Lemon Bread is an amalgamate that is made in Alphys's lab  ''from monsters that have FALLEN DOWN. ''Lemon Bread is probably a nickname from shyren's sister. I mean considering she isn't shyren's sister anymore. She is Shyren's Sister, and whoever else fused with her.

And how does that even mean it was written before??? it says FALLEN DOWN?? Even you said it was made from monster's that have fallen down.

There you go again. You yourself said that Lemon Bread is a combination of Shyren's sister and other monsters, not "Shyren's sister," which is a single person. If "Lemon Bread" was a nickname for Shyren's sister, then that would be mentioned before Shyren's sister became an Amalgamate, which it never is.

You keep using the "fallen down" line as though it proves your point, but it doesn't. Your confusion comes from the belief that when Shyren's sister "fell down," it was referencing after she became an Amalgamate. But the timeline is clear here: the monsters that became Amalgamates were sent to the True Lab because they fell down, which means the "falling down" occurs before they become Amalgamates. You can just read Entry #6: "ASGORE asked everyone outside the city for monsters that had "fallen down." Their bodies came in today. They're still comatose... And soon, they'll all turn into dust. But what happens if I inject "determination" into them? If their SOULS persist after they perish, then... Freedom might be closer than we all thought."

So the timeline is as such: Alphys begins research, Shyren's sister falls down, Shyren's sister is sent to Alphys, Alphys injects determination into the monsters, the monsters turn into Amalgamates which includes Shyren's sister fusing with other monsters into Lemon Bread. The reference in Mettaton's diary is to when Shyren's sister fell down, before she was turned into an Amalgamate. He has no idea who Lemon Bread is.

Yeesh... Why you trying so hard to debunk me? That's how theories work. If it can't survive even basic scrutiny, then the theory is bad and needs to be either revised or rejected.