Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-27524978-20160210030742/@comment-27724045-20160331233212

Brainifyer wrote: Well I wasn't showing evidence, just my opinion. If you want eveidence here it is:

1)Bones are organic, the Phase Disorter would have destroyed these too.

2)Papyrus' suit was made a ffew weeks ago.

3)Why would Ness adopt a Starman as a brother?

4)I've never played EarthBound, but from what I've heared Sans and Ness have completely different personalities.

5)Ness can kill/level up, why would Sans be so objected to it?

6)Why would Sans have only 1 for each stat, whwen Ness can have much more?

7)Sans' powers are only similar to Ness', Sans is much more powerful and uses vastly different attacks.

8)Frisk can somehow recognize Sans as Ness in the photo

9) Toby Fox said the Halloween Hack embaressed him, why would he create a direct sequel?(Best Evidence)

I suppose a few of these could be explained away, but really the whole theroy felt like MatPat desperately trying to link his favorite game to Undertale. 1: It was never directly stated it destroys ALL organic material, as it was never tested.

2: Just because Sans said that doesn't make it true.

3: If the Starman got teleported with him and wasn't a total jerk I don't see why he wouldn't.

4: Ness is a silent protagonist, he literally has no personality.

5: Few things you fight in Earthbound actually dies, this is even directly stated right after almost every battle.

6: Sans' 1 HP may only be put there as a placeholder, the same goes for his attacks.

Because no matter how much he has of either, it doesn't really matter in the longrun since most players will be using the Real Knife and The Locket.

7: Ness really isn't anymore powerful than Sans.

8: It's not directly stated Frisk can recognize Sans, that's the narrator of the game saying it's 'Sans and a bunch of people you don't recognize.' it doesn't say Frisk DOES recognize Sans.

9: The Halloween Hack doesn't HAVE to be part of the theory.

Sans could have easily got sent there sometime in any version of the story.

The Halloween hack just serves as an easy explanation for that.

I just explained ALL of those away.