Thread:TheHumanAmbassador/@comment-30937172-20181013191124/@comment-32182236-20181013193414

Actually, it's worse. That theory at least had merit to it, the sprites looked completely different. Sometimes it's easier to believe that the different colored sprites actually mean two different people than to say this is the same person and the color change was completely meaningless. (Yeah, Scott isn't/wasn't [Has he changed since then?] one for consistency.) Now, if they said that he DID do the murders, but that's COMPLETELY justified because the kids were acting up and painted him purple, you'd get closer to the Chara Defense Squad's arguments. Here, there's no such sprite error, and in fact taking minute details into consideration actually leads AWAY from Chara's actions being defendable. And Toby does a far better job, the intro sprite of the fallen child not matching Frisk's was a plot point, not some silly mistake like that.