Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-34798955-20180310144518/@comment-32182236-20180608111111

"The Real Knife is the genocide version of the worn dagger."

Worn Dagger:15ATK Real Knife:99ATK

See now the problem? I bolded it for you.

"And I believe Chara is the narrator. So when it says the worn dagger is perfect for cutting plants and vines, that could mean Chara loved gardening."

No, that only implies they KNEW about that, and considering how they both knew what buttercups was.. They probably do.

"I don’t think ANYTHING in the game said Chara wanted to kill the entire village, just the 6 humans needed."

There is evidence they wanted to kill the whole village:And that's their plan of taking thier own dead body out in the village where everyone can see it, causing them to all attack, so that Chasriel would then kill them all. If they didn't want to kill the whole village, then why did they do this?

"Frisk/player caused their reincarnation, they called them around to learn why."

And the reason became clear:It was their power that brought them back.

"We DO name Chara instead of Frisk so I think Chara represents the player’s desires, and Frisk is the player’s actions."

No, we name Chara because they're the narrator, their name appears as our stats.. And that'd make a plot twist.

...Frisk, and only Frisk, is the player.

If you want to make things meta, than I can do that too:So here's my meta take!

In the Undertale Demo, there was no reference to Chara as a separate character than us. Perhaps the playable character was in fact Chara at this point. But, there was a glaring inconsistency between the child who fell in the intro and the child. Once this was caught notice of, Toby then decided to make Chara their own character, to make the mistake no mistake.

"The “Chara kills everyone at the end of soulless pacifist” thing is a theory. It’s most likely just a reminder of what we did in genocide. That the game remembers what happened."

They possess Frisk, and either make an evil laugh or X out everyone on the photo. And what does Xing out someone from a photo indicate? That they're ones you want to KILL.

"And Frisk becomes evil because the player commands it."

...Frisk IS the player, according to canon. The player as a seoarate entity does not exist at all in the game's canon. Just like any other RPG ever:In Zelda, we ARE Link. In Undertale, we ARE Frisk.