Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-26907577-20191002153041/@comment-32182236-20191031115544

Yes, that is the basis of my claim. If a war happened the first time, it'll likely happen the second time as well. Though this doesn't quite debunk the wizard hypothesis, as this is inductive, rather than deductive.

Though since the reasons for the war still technically exist, and humans will likely fight over it again.

And the lack of humans in the True Pacifist Ending is still quite.. Disturbing.

Though I now believe that this town might be a town created entirely by the monsters, like Hometown from Deltarune.

In fact, for all we know, that town might very well be Hometown. That is, Undertale's equivelant of it. In this case, that simply means humans and monsters haven't integrated with each other yet. I suppose it'll be a while until Frisk gets old enough to actually serve as an ambassador.

I've been attempting to find ways that the wizards could avoid a second war, and the best I could come up with was trying to subtly influence them. But I don't see how seven humans could have much of an effect on the human population as a whole.

Though I don't think it's a problem with the hypothesis (yet). It's a problem with our understanding. (Which may or may not turn out to be an actual problem with the hypothesis) If I did call it a problem with the hypothesis just for that, that'd be an argument from incredulity, since I also don't have reasons as to why they should fail. (Though I'd imagine they'd just be considered crazy, like those who disagree with the norm on other things, if they tried to directly make arguments in the monsters' favor. Which would result in a failure.)

Though I do see them checking out a few books to never return them.. The internet wasn't a thing, so that would indeed remove the information.

And by the time Chara fell, the idea that those who fall never return has been reduced to legend.

But wouldn't the Barrier breaking and the humans seeing the monsters coming out of them prove the legends to be true? What happens next? The plan was to eventually break the Barrier.. If it wasn't, then the reincarnation bit doesn't work, and the reincarnation bit was needed to explain the anomaly of SOUL colors.

So what happens next? What path is there that which leads away from the second war?

If a monster absorbs a human SOUL like "Kanashi" (still can't think of a better name) did.. There's almost cerainly going to be another war.

And this "Kanashi" monster is evidence that monsters can be bad enoug to do such a thing.

..Well, maybe. There are a few possibilities, that I'll attempt to go over. And I may have even missed some.


 * 1) "Kanashi" never existed (so where did the glyphs depecting such a monster come from? What tipped off to the humans that monsters can do this?)
 * 2) The SOUL absoprtion was NOT an evil act (BlackFootFerret in fact has stated that it could have been accidental. How can you "accidentially" absorb a SOUL?) Even still, this still means such an absoprtion could possibly happen again, which means as the time frame gets larger goes on, the probability that it will have happened within that time frame will approach 1. (BFF would also say that Kanashi is the origin of Boss Monsters-The first one.)

-

Why would the wizards specifically need to pick humaans that happen to match their SOUL colors? And how could the wizards pick out these humans past their death?