Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-26006155-20181123023529/@comment-32182236-20181208012050

I realize this is probably a game to most of you. So I'm sorry if I seem like an overly serious stick in the mud.

Oh, for me it's quite the opposite. I don't think you're taking the game seriously enough. When it comes to theorizing masterpieces like this, there is no such thing as analyzing too seriously, or too much. It's HOW you analyze that counts. (Do it scientifically!) If you're doing it right, the more, the better!

This is why I would have the evidence be presented first, and the theory second. I'd go off of what evidence proves what, rather than assuming something to be true and only presenting evidence later on. The latter increases the risk of using circular reasoning by a lot.. And I want the theories to be solid.

Some of my theories seemed to be confirmed by a LEAK, and many theorists the community were suspicious of my accomplishment, and threatened to leave the fandom entirely and abandon the show, thinking that the show was now ruined.

..Wow. I would have seen that as proof that the show is solvable, and you helped prove how good it was after all, and took your theory as inspiration and as an example to all of us, so that we may all continue to solve the show! You've proven it wasn't just a bunch of nonsense! That's a good accomplishment! ..I guess they thought you solved EVERYTHING. Even though you didn't explain exactly HOW they might go about bringing Pink Diamond back, and there's still an ending left to solve. Hopefully the producers take your accomplishment into consideration, and craft a bigger puzzle than ever before, now knowing the theorist community is capable of solving such complex puzzles. That is, after enough fans follow your footsteps..

But I can see why you stepped down. You wanted the mystery to remain a mystery, so that the community could work together, since you didn't want your presence to solve everything for them..

"Why does Clam Girl keep talking about YOU having a neighbor named Susie? Because that's also true in Earthbound Zero."

The name Clam Girl says is actually "Suzy", not Susie. There's a difference. Look closely at the text again. Also, it's HER neighbor's daughter. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XsiSnVFscsU

So don't worry, some of that evidence doesn't support the Ness theory after all. You still have a chance at destroying that theory. :3

Oh, and by the way, in your "play", there's a HUGE problem. The monster SOULs combined make 1 SOUL. The only way it would make the "7th" would be if 6 already exist, but if Gaster fell before 201X, this is impossible. So.. yeah. Hopefully you solve that.