Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-26006155-20190403163405/@comment-32182236-20190418122351

Or why Dr. A married a woman and actually had a child with her. Or why his attitude towards his family suddently *changed* when, if he was into guys, it should have been consistent from the beginning.

There. Theory debunked. You don't need the "Story Potential" argument from emotion.

But when you pass over the easy explaination, and say that it's about grappling with Lying, and Dr. A feeling torn about telling his Wife a Terrible Truth or not.. sure it's more improbable, but it explains the rest of the Hack so much better!

"When you have eliminated the impossible, whatever remains, however improbable, must be the truth"-Sherlock Homes

So let's eliminate the impossible, shall we?

---

That suit had to be soaking wet at the time. But inspite of this William was still able to put it on, and it functioned perfectly for a few moments, giving him time to laugh, until suddenly ALL the springlocks all fired at once. Not a single failure, not a cascading domino effect.. BOOM, ALL the springs failed at exactly the same time. Something nearly impossible from statistical probablity.

Thus, unlike what it seems, this is actually LESS probable than the alternative, objectively speaking.

If the author really is a Good Author, then everything that can be solved using Story Potential can also be solved by using logic. After all, the story is consistent, right? The world isn't just a place of nonsense filled with deus ex machina whose sole purpose is to bring forth a common ideal, is it? We just need to solve this like a detective would.

But when you realize that the suit William just got stuffed into is the very same one he seems to have stuffed someone else into according go the FNAF 4 cutscene.. and that that suit is *already possessed* by the spirit of one of his own victims, who would *absolutely love* to perform an ironic act of revenge? Then all of these strange details make sense.

I always thought that SpringBonnie suit was one of the replacement suits Phone Guy mentioned, and that the Shadows were the temporary suits. The hats don't match.

Then again, Pink Guy's been confirmed to be one and the same as Purple Guy (Really, Scott?), so at this point, I'm not even sure where to go. Once evidence starts becoming not just red-herrings, not just unimportant details, but flat-out wrong, whatever story there is becomes impossible to solve, because you have no way of knowing what evidence is real, and what evidence is just as fake as Pink Guy being different than Purple Guy. It's as I said, the contradictions in FNAF made me quit.

But if Pink Guy became possessed, and that explains his change into Purple Guy, I might be coming back. What do you think of this possibility? The possession must have happened between Foxy Runners and SAVE THEM.

Speaking of which, let me show you the Phone Guy's Death.. Again.

You see, when Yellowbear jumpscares you, first he makes the garbled sound.. THEN the jumpscare happens. However, from Phone Guy's death, there is no garbled sound. The jingle happens, Chica or Bonnie groans, then the jumpscare happens... Instantly. The jingle was still playing just before then, meaning Phone Guy had to have STILL been looking at the Kitchen.

FNAF can't even follow its own rules correctly. That's why I've stopped trying to solve it.

-

I should probably get to responding to Chapter 7 pretty soon. But Ferret, I want to ask you again.. What makes you insist on adding the words "since we've talked" to the Mysterious Phone Call? The caller only says it's been a long time... And leaves it at that. We don't know what it's been a long time since. For all we know, it's been a long time since they made any real progress on their plan.