Talk:Eight Humans/@comment-33170295-20171205013847/@comment-28517148-20171217125619

Human Soul will shatter only from direct hits, like Frisk's during their fights with a monsters. On the surface, villagers could attack only Asriel's body. They even didn't manage to finish him off, so when his body turned into dust, Chara's Soul did the same what it has done when they died from poisoning - it persisted, because this is in their nature. If Chara's Soul shatter, there will be no way to bring them back to life, no logical explanation why they are with Frisk from the begginning, because nothing has left - the body has died and rotted and soul shattered and is gone. It must to survive. In the other hand, if Chara's Soul stayed in untouched condition after Asriel's death, there is no good explanation why monsters didn't find it and take care of it. Therefore, it cannot survive. Houston, we have a plot hole.