Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-32182236-20170602170443/@comment-27089028-20170908205709

TheHumanAmbassador wrote: 1-The ancient plaques have something to say about that.

2-The monsters were able to kill six humans. Really, once they absorb a single SOUL, they can kill some other humans rather quickly, and add to their power at an incredible rate. It's really not hard to go from one to seven. The hardest part is getting from zero to one. And Asgore managed to do that six times-He didn't absorb any of the SOULs.

3-Asriel had no "evil" intentions. Asriel Dreemurr was soulless, and lost his ability to love, which ultimately lead him to becoming the evil flower we know him as. What we did was restore Asriel Dreemurr to his former self. But what if someone's original nature was, well.. To kill?

Actually, monster SOULs are not composed of love, compassion, and hope. That is mere propaganda. Here's a few questions we must raise about the book.

1-How did the monsters come to this conclusion? Those concepts can't be "measured", there's no way to scientifically come to this conclusion.

2-If monsters are supposedly made of love, then why does Undyne hate humans? If they're made of hope, how did they "lose" it after Chara and Asriel died, yet not go extinct? And if they're made of compassion, then why did the monster within the plaque asborb that human SOUL? Look I get that you're really into this idea about a rogue monster going ape shit on the surface but uuuuuh that's kind of defeating the message of the game a bit don't you think? The RPG where nobody has to die and get hurt, sure your take on it is probably very realistic (if not a little too paranoiac) but not really what Toby was going for. Yeah of course a Monster could kill 7 humans (you make it sound like such an easy thing to do when almost every Monster that killed Frisk failed to actually capture said soul) but like...who would do that, every Monster who could have and would have has succumbed to Frisk's talk no jutsu heck even Flowey says "yeah have a nice happy ending."