Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-32930821-20170823152312

OK, let me explain:

We all know that the Underground during a Pacifist or a Genocide run is the same; same character, same location, same relationship beetwin PNGs, same time, same starting situation. The only things that changes is our (and so our character's) behavior. That's changes how the PNGs interact with us. But there is and assymmetry: in Pacifist we controll a child, Frisk, who falls down and becames friend with evryone, while in Genocide we controll The First Human (or Chara) who resurrects from death.

And if in Pacifist we controlled Chara the whole time?

At the end of Genocide Chara says that the protagonist's "determination" and "human soul" awakened them from death, and then she adds that she didn't know why she was alive, but throught our guidance she realized the real pourpose of her reincarnation. That things could have happened also in the Pacifist Run, she becames alive, she doesn't understand, we teach her to be friend with evryone and she understand her pourpose is to free the underground/save Asriel. Toriel buried Chara in Ruins as well as she did before the Genocide Route.

That would explain why in Pacifist we listen Asgore voice after a death (the same things he told to Chara when she was dying, why we remember the first meeting with Asriel after the fall in waterfall, and why we dream Asgore if we sleep on the bed in Ruins after killed/spared Toriel. Also the very similar outfit of Frisk and Chara can be explained by this theory, and why Chara's soul (or the soul we gave her) is red as well as Frisk's one. She didn't tell the trought to other monsters for the same reason Asriel doesn't come back after we free him, and she invents the name Frisk when Asriel asks.

Personally i think this is the truth, because there is a lot of references to facts in game and resolves the asymetry i said before, is not a over-speculated theory. I wanted add a page to this wiki, but i think this is a better place to talk about this.

What do you think about the theory? let me know pls ^.^ 