Thread:BlackfootFerret/@comment-32182236-20190319173036/@comment-32182236-20190322233200

Alright, I'll be responding to this. To expose the absurdity of the argument right in front of the entire jury! *screen crack visibly seen*

..And you just broke the 4th wall. Well, I'll use this time to clear up your misunderstanding.. Then we'll try to find out how to fix this.

-

The name "Kanashi" is, and always was, a fan name. I've adapted the name because I couldn't find another, better one, but we don't know who this mystery monster's name actually is. So, we can't use its meaning to find out how canon Kanashi is. So all we can deduce is that Camilia Cuevas probably believes that Kanashi was good. And if Our Leaders actually makes a good defense of Kanashi, that's one thing, but until that defense is actually made (I'm not sure when the first episode of Our Leaders will actually air), the fact that Camilia probably believes in a good Kanashi is meaningless. Beliefs must be justified.

Now come on little dog. Let's fix this.

...What? No, not my VHS tape! I was going to use that as evidence in Chara's trial!!

Very well. Since Kanashi's alive, the wizards probably are too. I'll just have them fix things. And I can always find that tape again in the True Lab on a new save file. --

..Themes? Themes? I've said once before that I don't believe Undertale really has much of a theme, besides that things aren't the way they seem. And one final inversion by revealing the humans were the good guys all along, and taking away the idea that all monsters are good can most definitely fit. *another crack*

Ferret, are you TRYING to break the fourth wall?

---

Anyways, on to Kanashi. I've already stated that I do not necessarily believe that Kanashi killed anyone. Just that they stole a SOUL. You may have noticed that I never charged them of murder. If I believed they must have killed someone, you'd think I'd charge them with that too, right? They were no war criminal, let's just get that straight.. If they absorbed enough SOULs, they'd be able to succeed at destroying humanity, and yet, here we are, surviving, able to banish the monsters underground, and now Frisk has released the monsters once again. But they were someone who saw a human SOUL, and wanted it for himself. Perhaps they were a kidnapper? Or maybe, they just wanted to take that valuable item for themselves, to unleash the power of the SOUL. Whatever the reason, though, theft is theft. We have the face the facts. Emotional bias has no place in court!

And by the way, the statement that the humans had nothing to fear was an addendum to asking the question on why they attacked. This was then answered with the ability to absorb human SOULs. This was what the humans feared. It's really that simple.

If Rose was a gem power vampire, why didn't make sure Bismuth would NEVER talk to anyone again, and just devour her, instead of stashing her in Lion's mane where she could eventually (and did) escape?

That right there debunks the power vampire theory on its own. Theme has nothing do to with it. You made a good call scrapping it, but theme was not the reason why said theory was flawed.

but what if we were wrong about Pink Diamond? What if she sacrificed herself and made Steven because it was the only way to save both the Earth, and Homeworld itself?

That too is wrong. She shattered herself to create Rose Quartz. She left because of how corrupted the other three gems were, and Rose Quartz, her alter-ego, didn't want anyone to find out she was Pink. Rose eventually created Steven, who would later go on to do what Pink failed to do..

A very detailed and improbably story.. but once that would be amazing to tell, and inspiring as all heck.

For someone as great as a Diamond, I wouldn't put it past them to make such a genius plot.

If I were writing the show, I'd definitely prefer ressurrecting Pink Diamond rather than shattering the others. It's just a better story with a better point at the end.

Wishful thinking doesn't get you anywhere...

---

How are Boss Monsters linked to humans? Sure, they're stronger, and can persist for a few seconds, and one was likely responsible for six human deaths (But it's not certain-Undyne could have been responsible for some as well. Since we cannot prove Asgore killed them himself, I'm not charging him-Especially since you could argue that the humans that fell illegally entered the kingdom of the monsters.), but this could just be similar to queen bees-Boss Monsters simply being a special type of monster, as described by the glyphs that introduce the concept.

Asgore was the king of the monsters, and Gerson proves he was the first. If Kanashi was a Boss Monster, then his death would precede the existence of the monster kingdom-And in that case, the absorption would be a long time before the war actually started.

Asriel's SOUL absorption was a part of a plan to co-conspire murder. I'll be charging both him and Chara for that in another trial. (I already mentioned this trial before) There WERE evil intentions there.