Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-26006155-20190425222457/@comment-26006155-20190610004155

Phone Guy and William are definitely seperate people.

Listening to Henry's tapes in FNAF 2, he lets us know where William, Night Guard 01, is in the background of each call.

In the first FNAF 2 tape (replayed from Michael's first shift in Summer 1983 because the details of that week and this week in Winter 1987 were so incredibly similiar that a new tape wasn't neccessary.., aka The Summer Paradox https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VHaJUF6hwC0 ) Phone Guy/Henry mentions how the restaurant has only been open for one week, and the guard before you/Michael/Jeremy requested a transfer to day shift.

This Guard 01 was William. We see him pop up in the Save Them minigame as The Purple Guy, a dead ringer for William's description in The Silver Eyes.

For whatever reason, William, Guard 01, assures Phone Guy that nothing bad happened last week. He's the guy on watch from open till close.

But as the week stretches on, the police investigation into the Save Them Massacre intensifies. And William bugs out, learning a worried Phone Guy to mention that a position in the day shift just became available.

Then the police lockdown happens, with a special emphasis on not allowing in "pervious employees". Aka William.

And on Night Six, which must be happening in real time because Phone Guy talks about timely events and still seeing Michael/Jeremy there, Phone Guy realizes a yellow suit in the back has been used. Which, if this is related to the FNAF 3 call, would be Spring Bonnie.

And then, on Night 7, "Fritz Smith", a name that translates to "Maker of Freddy", mysteriously appears and gets a pink slip.. for the very same reasons William was furloughed at the end of FNAF 1. Odor and tampering with the animatronics.

Purple Guy came back into the building, using the secret passage into "The New and Improved Freddys" that connects to the Afton House. FNAF 2 doesn't have a kitchen, yet somehow tons of pizza is being made. The Afton House, meanwhile, does have a kitchen. And only Afton Family members, which seem to make up ALL the employees there, would know about this passage.

So I really don't understand your objection to Phone Guy getting killed in FNAF 1.

Why is it impossible?

Henry and William are two different bodies that each share opposite parts of the same soul. And Michael is William's second son.

In FNAF 1, Michael has already been bitten, his endoskeleton trapped inside "Freddy", the recolored Fredbear suit controled by Shadow Freddy. William is in the hot seat as out protagonist. And Henry.. gets eaten in the Night 4 tape.