Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-32182236-20190721003717/@comment-26907577-20200110004015

Hmm. I think you're dodging the real disagreement here.

There may be multiple theories hypotheses that account for all of the evidence.

You want to judge these by how much sense they make to the author. And I would agree, if we could formally judge what we're looking for.

We can't, so I judge them by Occam's Razor. Not interconnectedness or Story Potential.

Your approach is to discard that much of the formality. True?