Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-26006155-20190425222457/@comment-32182236-20190610013327

It's not that Phone Guy couldn't have died. It's that he couldn't have died exactly the way the recording says he did, if the animatronics are bound by the rules we see them bound by in actual gameplay. I said, give a model of his death that fits all the evidence-Not just a model of his death that results in us observing him die. And just because you solved my first objection doesn't make every other objection null and void-They're all independent of each other.

...Oh, you meant the sound AFTER the jumpscare, not before/during.. Alright, in that case, the FNAF3 paradox goes away. (Where I mention the inconsistent time scales of a springlock failure.) I interpreted it as during/before the roar, which might be Foxy's knocking (but if it is, that's inconsistent with the way he acts in actual gameplay.) Now do you understand why I said it happened during the whole call?

-

I already believed in the Two Villain Theory.. And when the Freddy Files crushed that hypothesis, I declared the story of FNAF forever lost. That's the moment I completely lost hope in FNAF. As you PROVED, they cannot be the same person. What, is FNAF in a quantum superposition of canons?

By the way, its declaration was indirect. It never said Pink Guy and Purple Guy were the same directly.. It implied that by referring to Pink Guy as "the aforementioned Purple Guy", as if they were literally the same instance of the same character. It doesn't seem to suggest that they're two parts of a whole, but rather, the same thing exactly-Which completely contradicts huge pieces of the lore! The Two-Villain Theory is both 100% true and 100% false. And that's a problem.

---

Ferret, you had more direct evidence to prove that Phone Guy expected to die... And you didn't use it!

"Hey, listen. I might not be around to send you a message tomorrow. It's been a bad night here-For me. Um, I-I'm kinda glad I recorded these messages for you.. um, when I did"

One could easily presume that Phone Guy was referring to endoskeletons.. And wondering what was inside the empty heads (the entire body couldn't fit inside the head). But here, Phone Guy is making it clear that he does not expect to be around tomorrow..

...Actually, now that I think of it, I can see why you didn't use it. Perhaps one could have interpreted it as Phone Guy having a bad day, and deciding it was time to quit before he goes insane.. And he's glad he recorded the messages while he had a chance..

But that interpretation breaks down when we consider that in Night 1, he mentions that it's his last week. While we don't know why he was quitting, such a gradual progression to quitting doesn't make much logical sense.

Phone Guy believed that there was a reasonable chance that he would die. A high enough chance that he needed to mention it.

One of the animatronics got into the office-If Foxy was banging, then Chica made the moaning sound. Chica got into the office.

If Chica got into the office, Phone Guy didn't check the east light and close the door, so he was probably pretty low on power. So it's reasonable to be worried about dying. Once the moaning sound was heard, that's when Phone Guy says "oh no".. Because once that sound is heard, an animatronic is in the office. You're as good as dead.

Everything makes sense... Until Yellowbears's sudden jumpscare.

You see, the fate of Mike and the fate of Phone Guy are entangled... If Yellowbear can insta-kill Phone Guy, she should also be able to insta-kill Mike.. And if she can't insta-kill Mike, she shouldn't be able to insta-kill Phone Guy.

And yet, according to the evidence, we see her insta-killing Phone Guy... But in order for Yellowbear to kill Mike, he first has to look at West Hall Corner when it's haunted by Yellowbear.. Then, she'll appear, and make garbled noises.. She'll sit by idly for a few seconds (or a few minutes if we convert to real-world time).. And only THEN can she kill Mike. Mike can even dispel Yellowbear by bringing up the monitor.

There's no logical reason for Phone Guy to look at West Hall Corner at this point, because the west door would have been closed. However, if the sound that appears to be Foxy's knocking is something else instead, we can discredit this-Perhaps the west door was actually open, and Phone Guy had a reason to look at that location. If this is the case, then perhaps the reason why Phone Guy didn't check the eastern hall is because he was busy checking the western hall, and Chica slipped in that way.

But a more concerning problem, that can't be explained away exists. ...We don't hear these garbled noises preceding Phone Guy's death. And yet, she HAS to do this to Mike. That is the paradox. The very mechanics of the death are inconsistent. It's as I said-The very rules defining how the animatronics function are inconsistent.