Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-28925112-20160730202210/@comment-29436648-20160805142457

EgamIrorriM wrote: ToyFroggit wrote: Interesting theoy, but I would rule out Papyrus and Undyne because they're probably kids at that time. My own theory on how the souls died is that the first soul, Patience, maybe could've died from Mupphet, but since the weapon and equipment the Aqua soul had was considered to be one of the weakest. I won't be surprised if the soul died from a Loox or a Vegetoid. The orange soul, Bravery, probably died from one of the sentry dogs because they're part of the Royal Guards and they always hang out around Snowdin. The blue soul, Integrity, maybe just died from a random Waterfall enemy. Purple soul, Perseverence, could've died from the old turtle. The reasons why I believe that is One: He used to be part of the Royal Guard and was considered to be the strongest and Two: He was selling the cloudy glasses and the torn notebook which the Purple soul had. The Green soul, Kindness, obviously died in the Hotlands and was probably killed either by the Royal Guards or a random Hotland Enemy. The Yellow soul, Justice, who made it the farthest, most likely died in the CORE because the soul's weapon and equipment was being sold near MTT reasort and the monsters in the CORE is pretty powerful. (Reminder: Mettaton is unlikely to kill the Yellow soul because he didn't get his body yet, probably is still in his ghost form and hanging out with Napstablook in the Waterfall.) Note: The Yellow human has to die in Waterfall, as seen that the items from Bratty & Catty were actually from the Garbage Dump, so in order to have his/her items picked up by Bratty & Catty, he/she has to die IN the Garbage Dump.

                                                                               -OR-

The six humans have to make their way past all the regions and die during the battle with ASGORE, so that makes more sense to have their souls collected in New Home.

P.S. In case if you don't know, the old turtle's name is Gerson. Well it is a probably that the Yellow soul died in the Waterfall, but I see a few flaws in that reasoning

1. I checked the Waterfall level of the dump and Alphy's date simulater background of the dump and I see no dumpster

2. Who would keep a dumpster in a dump? They could just let it pile in a heap

3. The Yellow soul was the SIXTH soul who came to the underground so the soul could've picked up a new item during the way.

And all of the six souls dying by Asgore's hand is not impossibility, but they don't have to die in the New Home so their souls have to be collected. Monster could just collected the soul and bodies of the humans and bring to Asgore.