Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-27089028-20181103002825/@comment-32182236-20181123153343

Really, I spotted a plot hole in MatPat's theory. Actually, two.

According to the theory, the Dark World was but a game for Kris and Susie. Question is, why did Susie change during the game, why did she want to play at all, and why did it begin (especially for Susie!) when they entered the closet?

The second is more serious:The closet is not the unused classroom. The closet is begind the top-middle door, the unused classroom behind the top-right door. Therefore, it would make no sense for Kris to not want to get the chalk because "they're afraid to show Susie their game", because the game isn't even IN the closet! They could have gotten the chalk, brought it gack to Alphys, and been done with it, rather than pretending to get trapped, and moving over to the Unused Classroom to play out their fall. And Susie seems surprised by the fact they somehow ended up in the unused classroom. This was never the plan.

MatPat did do a good job at explaining Susie herself, however.