Board Thread:Fun and Games/@comment-14248438-20160216161817/@comment-24633236-20160219145951

Both of them can't avoid getting hit by the other's attacks, because the aqua soul cannot move like the orange attack requires presumably, and viceversa. If this is the case, sice they are in the same level from the dodging point, we should consider their weapons and stats. The toy knife's only advantage is that it can cut, while the gloves can only punch, but according to the in-game stats orange is advantaged in both ATK and DEF. Orange will win after a long and hard fight.

But, if we consider the case that the aqua soul can move and that the orange can stop, knowing that probably the orange soul will "rush through all obstacles" and instead the aqua soul will have more PATIENCE but can and will move, from the dodging part the orange will fail a few times and the aqua will probably stop and move during the orange attacks with a instant and fast move, like a "sharp attack". The aqua soul could win, with a little bit of luck and after losing a considerable amount of HP.

The same last sentence applies if we consider that the orange soul will immediatly attack, rushing to the other soul and without thinking much about it; while the aqua soul has a strategy, and will wait for the better moment to attack suddenly with their knife.

Considering all this, aqua will have more probability of winning; I wouldn't bet on it, through. Really interesting question indeed, I don't know if I answered well.

Next battle is Burgerpants VS Toriel (We're picking random characters).