Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-26006155-20190425222457/@comment-32182236-20190510233110

Not Sans as Sans, Sans as Frisk!

Clearly, you didn't understand a thing about my response to Chapter 8. Here, let me try to make things more clear for you.

When Frisk and Gaster both first arrived, they were still human. You say they took the same journey that Beta Frisk did. If they took that same journey, then they were in their human forms, without any costumes. This would be when they learn about the monsters, and their stance towards humans.

So, one of the questions I was asking was, when was that journey? When did it happen? If that was the first thing they did, it'd explain how they knew to use disguises.. But not why we find Gaster before 201X. If we found Gaster before 201X, that means Sans, Papyrus, and Gaster must have all traveled back in time together the first time around. So we have an Alpha, a Beta, and a Gamma.

This would explain why Frisk didn't reset the first time.. But only if we have a reason why they would go so far back in time in the first place.

You say they came to the world to stop an anomaly.. But then things get carried away with freeing the monsters. Whatever happened to the anomaly sub-plot?

Gaster's Darkest Experiment apparently happened after 6 humans fell. They already had 2 more humans, though, and they were clearly willing to use themselves before, since they started the experiments before Chara fell.

You had Sans and Gaster try to go back to their world, when their reason for coming, stopping the anomaly, never finished.

When we start getting into the details of what your narrative entails, the many plot holes start to open up. You might have made a theory that looks good on its surface, but all I have to do is pull a few threads, and the many plot holes are revealed.

As I said many times before:Alpha Frisk is the downfall of your theory.