Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-26006155-20190425222457/@comment-32182236-20190511192529

It's as I said. The Alpha Timeline just has too many holes, when you try to analyze what actually happened.

Try to form a cohesive timeline of everything from Ness's and Andonuts' arrival in Undertale to the fall of Gaster. I think you'll run into a lot of contradictions.. I certainly have.

I should probably start Chapter 9 soon. After all, I said I was going to save the full Alpha Frisk rebuttal until the end. But before that can be started, I'll have to find out just what your candidates for what happened are.. So I can rule them out. Besides, maybe you said something in Chapter 9, 10, or 11 that saves your theory.. I doubt it, but I can't know for sure until I've actually analyzed them! After all, Chapters 0-8 were all just 66 pages long, and your theory lasts for 127 pages (not counting the notes at the end). Those last three chapters could give a more exhausted analysis...

We'll just have to find out, when I analyze Chapter 9.