Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-31981697-20170722123329/@comment-27136653-20170831183856

1) He would not waste his last moments like that.

2) Did I mention yet that the room is not canon, with no intended canon explanation? So why bother?

3) That's a fucking door handle. And I don't see how can DJ discs get obsolete. Piano keyboards didn't get obsolete, and so wouldn't DJ mixing discs, drum pads, mircophones, and other things. They'll get more efficient, but won't vanish.

4) No, you said everything past the intro is canon. I call that bs. The game menu is obviously not canon. So isn't naming the fallen human (at least not for Frisk, even though it does influence Chara's name), and so aren't the credits.

5) Why would the monsters lie? Why would they pass down hurtful knowledge if it wasn't the truth? What makes the plaques more reliable than whatever fancy talltale we were told? Perhaps their sole existence? What convinced you that Flowey is actually Asriel? Perhaps new information being shared? The point is, Toby included that information for a reason. New information updates the old one, and the intro was the older one. Since there's no hint that the plaques weren't being honest, then I don't see why can't they be telling the truth.

6) Chara might have said that line. Or maybe Aaron just assumed that we were checking him because, well, he WANTED us to check his body out. Besides, one monster knowing about the checks isn't really convincing. Why is there so few monsters that seem to be aware of the checks?

7) Well, unfortunately, unlike QM, the HUD doesn't make a mathematical sense, unless you acknowledge that it's not canon. Oh, and from point 14, how do you explain that the "world menu" has a joystick config? And yes, Flowey was, in a sense, in the game's menu. So... was it really canon?

8) Or, you know, two people CAN have the same name. Why would someone get reased from existence just because of picking an already taken name? If I remember correctly, the game prohibits the usage of certain names. So why did it not prohibit Frisk? And why bother, this isn't a theory anyways, just your speculation.

9) Glitch is when something happens in a way that shouldn't be possible. Assuming the world has the same laws as our world, but there's also magic on top of that, maybe the two clash with eachother and create glitches. For example, Gaster is pretty glitched himself, I'd say. The game crashes upon entering his name and whatnot. Seems like to some extent, "glitches" can be a real thing. If magic can be real, then glitched, non-magical reality can be a thing as well.

10) So... Frisk was at their peak determination during the fight with Asriel? I can believe that. But I still... I just don't see it. The same situation would apply during Omega Flowey's fight, so again, I don't really get WHY was it like that.

12) Yes. So she DID leave out of spite for Asgore, before he even killed the first human to come.

13) You can cry out of laughter too. And since I don't really see how would that specific situation make anyone cry so much (especially Chara), I simply assumed that Chara meant a sarcastic, overexaggerated laugh. Since it makes more sense.

14) If Frisk was present, Flowey would have formulated that sentence differently. It's rude to talk about someone in 3rd person when they're listening. Flowey was polite in that scene. It's hard to imagine that he would actually talk about Frisk like that, if he knew that they were in there too. And besides, it actually makes sense to say he was talking to the player, outside of the canon story. He possibly couldn't know about Chara. Maybe he knew that there was a narrator, but there's no way he could have known that it was actually Chara. He even said hurtful things about them when we visited him, so he didn't know that Chara was there with us. And so I'm asking, where did he acquire that knowledge from? Literally no one but Frisk knew who the narrator really was (or that there's a narrator in the first place), so either Asriel is a slow thinker, OR, he never thought so in the first place. Which I consider to be the case.

15) Why would Sans want to hide our soul in the first place? What if it's just a different way of activating the battle interface?