Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-32182236-20190721003717/@comment-26907577-20191008154744

Oh my.

I've realized something.

Either the Ball Game was created before the six humans fell, while the six humans fell, or after the six humans fell. Let's call these Scenario A, Scenario B, and Scenario C.

In Scenario A, the Ball Game already knew the colors of the human SOULs. This is incredibly improbable, as it implies that either there are only seven colors, or the monsters correctly guessed the seven colors. And the probabilities are horrible if there are only seven colors.

In Scenario B, the situation is identical to Scenario C due to the fact that the cyan human never reached the Ball Game: Monsters created the game based on the traits of the six non-Chara humans. (If they included Chara, that's Scenario A because the red flag mentions all six other colors.)

In Scenario C, the red description was either generated procedurally (disproven by the cyan human never reaching the game), or added between Frisk's arrival in Snowdin and arrival at the game (unlikely as the game doesn't seem to be specifically designed for them.)

So Scenario A is most probable... But it requires accepting that there are only seven SOUL colors.