Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-28925112-20160730202210

I have a theory about how the fallen humans (not including Frisk and Chara) died. I think the light blue human was killed in the ruins, because that's where their items were found. Specifically, I think they were killed by Muffet. Even though Muffet wasn't in the Ruins when Frisk fell, she could have been there earlier. Actually, we know she has been to the Ruins, because she has a mini bake sale there. She could have been there when the light blue human was passing through, and killed them. In addition, I think Muffet may have killed the green human as well. The green human's items are found in Hotland, which is where Muffet's main bake sale is located. I think that the green human fought Mettaton and was badly injured (the state of the green human's items supports the theory that they were hurt), but managed to escape and ran into Muffet, who easily killed them. The green human could have also been killed by the Royal Guards, but this seems less likely. Now for the yellow human. Their items are sold by Bratty and Catty, whose shop is located right outside of the MTT Resort. I think that the yellow human also fought Mettaton and lost, but barely managed to escape, later dying of their injuries. Bratty and Catty then found the items. The purple human probably died in or near Waterfall, possibly by Undyne. I think that they dropped their items in some tall grass, where they were later found by Gerson. Undyne later killed the purple human. Undyne probably also killed the blue human. The blue soul is associated with jumping, so they may have been leaping around in the tall grass rather than hiding from Undyne, who easily found and killed them. Finally, we have the orange human. Their items are located in Snowdin, and orange attacks in battle only deal damage if the player holds still. Because of this, I think that the orange human was defeated by Papyrus. They were probably constantly running through his blue attacks, resulting in him capturing them. Undyne then killed them and took their soul, leaving the items behind. The items were then found and taken to the Snowdin Shopkeeper, who now sells them. So yeah. That's my theory about how the humans died. What do you think? 