Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-26696192-20161025134039/@comment-27701762-20161026032124

While the second follower says he fell into his own creation, the first follower says that he was scattered across space and time. Which would be entirely consistent with the second follower says.

The question is simply what you consider "alive." If being shattered into millions of moments that are spread throughout space and time is still "life," then sure, Gaster is still alive. If not, then it would be better to stick with what Pancry said: he is in a state that is neither dead nor alive.