Talk:W. D. Gaster/@comment-27284424-20151125234936/@comment-27291644-20151126073044

I thought the same thing. Muffet said he had a nice smile, and mettaton was just a box at that point so he couldn't smile. Flowey would also have been a good suspect at first, but at this point he couldn't really "change shape", only change his face a bit.

But I also have my doubts because why would Gaster want your soul, and asuming the mystery_man is Gaster, why doesn't he just attack you if he want's your soul.