Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-26006155-20190820122909/@comment-26006155-20190903142255

Chara can't have been the first human to *ever* fall. Asriel says the mountain had a reputation for people not coming back from it long before Chara.

There was defnitely a monster society before Asgore's, that also got sealed underground. And somehow found a way out of it. So you have to separate what the ancient Waterfall Glyphs say compared to the modern libarby books, they had different authors at different times.

There's nothing random about events in a mystery. It's been crafted to confound. And if you go in expecting an even distribution of humans over time, you might blind yourself to other evidence.

You still have to tell me how Toriel acquired a modern handheld video recorder under her own power, before Gaster arrived and inspired the move to New Home. All of which happened before Chara even arrived.

And why Chara is wearing a modern outfit when she fell, similar to Frisk's. Which the intro cites as 201X.

Frisk describes the 201X calendars as "old". Not "ancient".

And why would Toriel have kept a copy of a 400-year-old calendar in a prominent part of her house, yet no copies of any decades after that? The "Beginning of 201X" calendar is likely there in Home because it's when people moved out, and when Toriel stopped updating it.