Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-34798955-20180310144518/@comment-37277678-20181105132914

I think the issue with whole Chara isn't evil theory is that it just blames the player and frisk for literally everything they do and say. Like they're some kind of blank slate who personality is influenced by the player's actions which we know is bs. The tapes show that Chara has there own thoughts and personality completely independent of the player.

And whole the idea that we somehow taught her that killing was okay through our actions on the genocide route is completely laughable. since We know for a fact they were willing to murder a village full of innocent men women and children in order to complete their plan. And this was all long before the player decided to kill anyone.

Also I'm fairly positive that it's the game that's punishing you in ( by having a psychopath possessor body and kill people) the end of the soulless pacifist route not Chara.. I mean you're telling me the entire reason why she's killing these innocent people is to show me that killing is wrong even though she was totally willing to kill people long before I was?

At best you can say she's an anti-villain a well-meaning extremist. But you definitely can't call her a hero or even an antihero for that matter since anti-heroes at least go out to people worse than them and not innocent villagers.