Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-26006155-20181123023529/@comment-35806478-20181130212507

Chapter 3: Speculation About Gaster

This chapter doesn't have that much evidence to back it up. It's mostly just baseless speculation, with only the last paragraphs having any sort of evidence to create some theories. So, let's examine those.

You claim that Alphys - or, I'm sorry, "Alyph" - jumped all the monsters through a dimensional portal. Your evidence? Chara destroys the world at the end of the game. And since obviously Alphys knew about this event that only happens at the very end of the Genocide Route - since we all know that Alphys can see into the future - that means that Alphys has a dimensional portal. I am definitely not being sarcastic in any way, shape, or form.

You also claim that Frisk went through said portal to go back in time, because there's no way they could have gone through the barrier with just a human SOUL. Except...how do we know that a human and monster SOUL are required to go through the barrier? It's just as possible that this is part of the same legend that states that a human and monster SOUL combined together creates a powerful and horrible beast, and that adding on more human SOULs gives you god powers. Or, maybe, this is a theory of Alphys that she believes is completely true. Either way, there's no proof a monster SOUL is required for a human to get through the barrier.

I am really hoping you give me something more substantial to argue against next chapter.

End of Chapter 3