Thread:ChildOfTheMoon3/@comment-5956954-20170516091426/@comment-26185073-20170516103249

Cheeseskates wrote: As the title states:
 * 1) The additions over-detail various aspects of the game when the section does not support such points (for example, telling people about Chara's "creepy smile". Be brief and concise.
 * 2) Related to over-detailing, adding additions without the appropriate reference for people to verify with (for example, "Papyrus likes spaghetti" ). It otherwise looks like speculation, and most of it is speculation anyway as you admitted with adding "fanon" content because the page somehow is. The wiki does not accept that. It must document every fact when necessary.

I hope this clears some issues. Most of this page very clearly runs with the theory that Chara is evil, despite how that's been disproven. If you read the page, it actually contains an awful lots of "mights" and speculation.

The Asriel section is almost entirely empty. That's their best friend, and Flowey references playing with them and having fun. Even Asgore's section is quite empty, despite the fact Flowey implied favourtism or more trust.

It mentions Narrator Chara as a theory, yet things that aren't directed confirmed or stated like Mettaton being a ghost, Alphys creating Flowey, etc being canon. It's implied, but it's never actually confirmed. Not to mention all the evidence Narrator Chara holds. (Like the reaction to the bed on the left, Asriel call reaction, etc)

I don't usually edit wikis, but it kind of annoys me when the Villains wiki page for Chara seems more accurate than the one on the actual Undertale wiki.

It's said to be CHARA when the player is moving on their own in Genocide. But FRISK moves on their own plenty of the time in Neutral/Pacifist. Example: When they DO hide behind the lamp. Or when Sans is taking a shortcut with them. What's the difference between the two? It seems more like both characters are being corrupted from LV to me, causing Frisk to start acting on their own.

and for some strange reason.. It doesn't mention one interesting fact, Asriel's sweater/shirt is light green and bright yellow. Chara's sweater/shirt is bright green and light yellow. Actually, that's not the main issue here.

If it must document every fact when necessary, though, what about all the facts about Narrator Chara? It's very, very obviously ignoring that. It acknowledges it like once? It's a big part of the game. They literally say "It's me, Chara", "It's you!" "Despite everything, it's still you" and "Still just you, Frisk." (notably, only AFTER the name is revealed).

Temmie did say Chara is chill, so there's no reason for it to be written as though Chara is evil, anyways.

Not really, I have almost never edited a wiki in my life.