Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-26006155-20181123023529/@comment-32182236-20181209150155

Have you considered that the reason why your theory has all these gaps is because it's fundamentally flawed? Just like Newtonian physics were?

I see a flaw, and I see it as a problem with the theory. You can't fix a fundamentally flawed theory. I don't have a solution, and I don't think there IS one, because the basis of your story is simply incorrect. Filling in the gaps of your theory is just like trying to fill the gaps in alchemy. One of the main skills a scientist must learn is when to know that they got it all wrong.

Anyways, let's take a look at your way of patching the hole, that's about as strong as putting a bandage over a deep, serious wound.

Under this pretext, Sans and Gaster both went back to before Frisk fell, which appears to solve the problem of Alpha Frisk not finding themselves in a "ghost kingdom". (Like a ghost town, but a whole kingdom of it.)

So, why go back at all? I suppose because the six SOULs vanished after Omega Flowey's battle, and they needed a point in time when they were still avalible. (His battle and motivations wouldn't really have changed with the lack of Sans, it'd just mean he'd finish his Genocide Run far sooner-Omega Flowey still would have happened.) So, they went back to probably just a little after the sixth human fell. (It has the most number of potential SOULs, and Papyrus has never seen a human.)

So, now, I have two questions. First, why didn't they try doing with Alphys did, but, put a someone's essence in that flower, so that they now have a willing participant, who now would just absorb all the SOULs, and break the Barrier? It'd be near instanteneous. Second, why bother genociding mankind at all when they already have EIGHT human SOULs?

If you're going to say they went back to there only being 4 human SOULs, so that even with them combined, they only have 6 SOULs, why would they do that? Why not pick the route where they have more SOULs to make the whole job easier?

So, Sans finds out the dark nature of the experiment, kills Gaster, then feels guilt, as his LV increases, and sees that he's locked out of Pacifist. Sans. JUST RELOAD! It's not that hard, you've been doing it for a long while! Just go back and try again, Sans! You lose your LV when you LOAD to before you killed someone!

By this point, we've devolved into nonsense.