Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-28885320-20160711182624/@comment-27089028-20170331191555

David The Potato wrote: Well, That would not make sense. You see Asgore and Toriel Divorced. Then Toriel escaped to the ruins after Chara died, and Asgore made a rule to kill all monsters. This was when Gaster was the Royal Scientist. I know this because Gaster did not "shatter himself across space and time" from falling in to the CORE. He did whene he was expirementing with DT, and what do you need to expirement with DT? A human soul. Now I am 100% sure it is from the DT extractor because if you look in a spectogram of Mus_Smile.ogg you see what appears to be a smile and the DT extractor on the top of the spectogram. Even toby confirmed in a livestream that there is a secret in "the spectoram". Now to obtain a human soul you have to kill a human, and Toriel is against murduring humans, so why would Gaster go tell Toriel "Hey Toriel I killed this human and something went wrong. You happy???" So who are theese two people? I believe one of them is Goner Kid, or the possible Gaster sprite in Room_Water_Redacted idk I just know it can't be both. It is an unfinished theory and it explains mostly everything in Undertale including the seven human souls and the reason why Undyne becomes Undyne the Undying (witch makes sense of this theory....) To Be Honsest it's an OK theory it's not the best, but hey im just a DETERMINED potato who wants to find out who Gaster is OK? As sound as your argument is, I disagree with you as you base this on the idea that Chara's death was before Gaster's incident therefore Toriel and Asgore would not have split plus the Shyren connection is hard for me to ignore. Alternatively, Gaster could be talking to someone else but I due to Sans and Papyrus 'appearing out of nowhere one day' definitely doesn't make me willing to accept they existed prior to Gaster's fall.