Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-34798955-20180310144518/@comment-32182236-20180531163249

@Rafip:That right there is why I don't consider True Pacifist as the best ending. Neutral's better, where everyone lives, with te monsters safely underground.

Monsters don't have a reason to leave the underground.. And indeed, they had no plans to, until Asriel died, causing Asgore to declare war in a fit of rage. It's for the reasons you said as well, as said by Gerson in the Genocide Route:This is why the war ended with a barrier. The human's goal was not to kill all monsters, but rather to banish them underground, behind a barrier, so that no monster may absorb a SOUL, and with unfathomable power, destroy humanity.

"Though monsters are weak, with enough SOULs... they could easily destroy all of mankind-"Monster History, Part 7 (datamined like Entry 17)

This was the reason for the war-It was more justified than you might think. And with monsters free, another war is bound to happen. Hopefully the monsters learn their lesson.. (And Glitchtale Betty has nothing to do with it.)

Either way, if Asriel killed those humans, there would be war against all of humanity. Chara WANTED to destroy ALL of humanity:They hated it, like Asriel said.

...A prime example of the danger of a monster with a human SOUL. Lucky for us, Asriel resisted.

Now, I have something to add to support your claim about the death of Asriel. Shadowly, while your take on the encounter seems interesting, I'm raising an objection:Why did Chara take their own dead body to the golden flowers in the first place? If they weren't trying to get the humans to attack, they had no reason to do this. Their wish about the flowers was an excuse to leave, so Chara had no reason to actually go through with it-Simply carrying it to the top of the mountain was enough:Nobody would see that Chasriel didn't go through with it, and nobody would be suspcious about Asriel killing a human like that, meaning the enocunter wouldn't have happened, Asriel wouldn't have died, and the plan may have had a chance of succeeding, with only SIX souls being used. Besides, even their wish about the flowers seemed suspicious-Why not just say you wanted to see the sun again, in preparation for this? We can't say they wouldn't be this prepared, considering how they showed their preparation skills in both Tape 4 and Tape 5.

The monsters doomed themselves, by freeing themselves. Considering how dangerous each side is to each other, they are not meant to live together.. For the safety of BOTH races.