Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-26006155-20190425222457/@comment-32182236-20190512014421

I'm just using your theory's premise when saying there was an Alpha Timeline. I already explained my real take. Before Gaster's fall, and after Gaster's fall are the only two timelines we know existed.

My real argument is that the Alpha Timeline, the way you presented it... is impossible. Instead, we have an impossible trio.

The Alpha Timeline cannot be:

Consistent, following Undertale's rules, and logically compatible with/logically leading up to the Beta Timeline.

And all three of those things it must be in order to be plausible.

Like I said, I'll get into why once I've fully analyzed your take on the Alpha timeline.

You'll find out why, once I've finished my analysis on your take. Once I do, I'll first try to work with you to find out just exactly what happened in your take in the Alpha Timeline.. Before I shatter that timeline entirely.

Or, try to at least. Your take might actually hold up. We'll just have to see.