Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-34798955-20180310144518/@comment-30701659-20180313203107

It still doesn't make sense from a CHARActer (I'll see myself out) perspective.

We agree Chara hates humanity. Good. But...when in the entire game does anything mention Chara hating monsters? The Dreemurrs took Chara in and gave them a loving home, Asriel even goes as far as to say they where best friends. And going off the waterfall thing, Mettaton flat out tells you about Alphys getting some of the monsters hidden away, including Monster Kid who SAW Frisk mortally wound Undyne, yet nobody forces you to go slaughter them.

Also remember the time when Chara ATE POSION in a very well made plan to free the monsters from the Underground? Asriel was the one who fucked that up. Asriel is the only person who Chara would be mad at. There's also some end of Genocide dialogue that doesn't match up with evil Chara, basically translating to "You want to go back to the world you destroyed... You think you are above consequences..."

Now, I also am not gonna argue Chara being a true pacifist. (I personally also saw Chara as more of an Anti-Hero or Chaotic-Good type, though that's just me), but I honestly don't agree with Genocidal Chara.

It's either that or Multiverse theory, with different timelines having Good and Evil Chara's. It's possible.