Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-26006155-20200107155350/@comment-26006155-20200113145925

Jacky, the comment wasn't aimed at you. I was responding for Ambassador's Years-Long-Pattern now of attacking my evidence rather than my arguments. I've heard the catchphrase "No Evidence" so often that it invokes PTSD.

Let's read it again:

-

TheHumanAmbassador wrote: It does mean that bit should probably be removed from the script, though. By only presenting the ACTUAL evidence, the theory is thus shorter. Besides, if people see bad/fake evidence, they might discount the whole based off of that anyway. So it's best to only keep the real evidence around, and base the case around that.

Unless Ferret has a defense to this. Then he can keep it in.

--

Congradulations, Ambassador. You found a weak point in my script where I thought the absense of "You Won" was unique to the Sans fight, which we've learned is not.

The Argument is weaker now, and probably should be changed. But there must still be some reason that "You Won" doesn't appear at the end of Boss Fights, even if it's no longer limited only to what happens to Sans.

But Ambassador goes much further than that:  Instead of viewing it as weaker, he jumps forwards to calling it flat-out fake, a statement that itself is making assumptions because it doesn't account for the difference with Boss Fights compared to regular ones.

He then repeats this same accusation several times over with different wording: "ACTUAL" "bad/fake" "discount the whole" "only keep real evidence". As if finding one mistake in my 70-page script is now grounds for throwing out the entire thing.

This isn't an argument, it's a Charisma Intimidate Check, calculated to cause as much pain as possible. As it is each and every time Ambassador makes an Appeal to Authority fallacy by listing the popularity of ideas as proof that they must be real.

The Burden of Proof has been on me ever since I began this adventure.

And rarely is any of my proof accepted, no matter how deep I dig and how careful I am.

I will rework the script based on the new knowledge that the absense of "You Won" after boss fights. One more tweak and revision in the constant evolution of my scripts that has been going on for years now.

But I have no intention of backing off from the theory that Frisk dies rather than Sans.