Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-29788596-20160906011125/@comment-33923105-20180602215941

Rafip wrote: @Evilwizard89013

I agree that char a is messed up and that they hated humanity (...) With that being said it is plausible that due to chara s relationship with humanity and how they were raised that they could be considered evil No, having parenting issues and being messed up doesn't make someone evil. Their deeds do. To become evil they must do something evil in the first place. Heck they persuaded you to commit genocide Wrong. Incorrect conclusion. came to the mountain to suicide (...) which i s led to believe that charas guardians were abusive or deranged Speculations. No value. ''But I believe nobody is truly evil with no reason... I don't think that evil people do evil things for no reason. They always have a motive whether it be for vengeance or to be noticed and remembered there is always a reason.'' Well, the fact is everyone have some reason behind their actions that later will be considered as evil or good. ''Evil people like char a simply didn't get delt a good hand in life so they ended up how they were raised. So I guess you could say she's evil but not out of her own accord but that wouldn't be true she has been through traumatizing things for her age which can lead to insanity.'' Chara still has free will and mind. They still are able to choose proper way without hurting anyone or themself. They chose wrong. And insanity would be very convinient excuse for their actions, making them immune for being evil, only sick.

Is Chara good or evil? They are definitely guilty of manipulating, puting in danger and finally causing death of a child. In wider perspective Chara's plan failed or not have made monster's life much more difficult. You choose if it's evil or not. Again I agree there guilty but I'm just saying they did it out of psychological trauma which isn't a good excuse but is the perfect motive