Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-26006155-20181229180615/@comment-32182236-20190128174430

I also believe in Charrator, and have made my own proof on the matter. Though I still don't believe they're some kind of hero. I've started developing my own hypothesis on the matter.. But just like how your core theory was there for 2 years but never fully developed.. I've never fully finished my hypothesis:It actually died out around the time that I moved on from pre-death Chara. (It does, in its current form, include proof of NarraChara and that Frisk is canonically one and the same as the player, though, and a hypothesis on what caused the fandom to split the way they did:https://undertale.fandom.com/wiki/Thread:151492)

--

As I hypothesized earlier, the key to Sans' room was given through timey-wimey hijinks. If you looked closer, I hypothesized the key itself wasn't hidden very well, since Sans knew only he would ever get to his room anyways, he has the key. Of course, given the note and its close proximity to the Silver Key, I've hence disregarded this explanation-If Frisk could read the note saying they just got owned, they probably can also see the Silver Key. Sans definitely had to have noticed it.

But I also had an alternative hypothesis:Sans would have done this for ANY human who went through the entire Underground without killing a single monster. It's not due to a relationship between Sans and Frisk, it's due to how Frisk has proven to be worthy of knowing the truth. And that's it. That's as far as it goes. Unless there's evidence that it goes even further than that...

---

Toby Fox just used a song from Homestuck because the name and situation, and the song fit the Sans battle. There is no in-universe link between Homestuck and Undertale. Undertale is its own separate universe. The Deltarune/Undertale connection is FAR more plausible, in fact. If you want to show an in-universe connection, use in-universe evidence, not song remixes. Until I see a character or a place from Homestuck in the Undertale universe, r a mention of one of those two things somewhere within the game, I will not consider the two as the same universe. Same thing for the Earthbound/Undertale connection (which is probably the biggest reason why I disbelieve in Sans is Ness)

Actually, that last one is LESS believable, considering that Toby Fox would then potentially be infringing on Nintendo's IP (Ness), placing them inside of a game that he is SELLING, that can be played without owning Earthbound. The Halloween Hack was legal because you needed to own the original Earthbound ROM to run it, and it was free. Toby is also fine with fan-games of Undertale as long as you don't SELL them. But I don't see how Toby could argue that selling a fan-game of Earthbound is fair use.