Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-26006155-20181123023529/@comment-32182236-20181208130101

I just discovered a temporal paradox in your theory.

And I'll show you how.

Let's go back to the "original" (actually second) timeline for a bit. So, we have Gaster doing his Dark Experiment, Sans killing Gaster, and then going back to help Frisk, his earlier version, from Timeline Prime.

Now, let's go back TO Timeline Prime. After all, Frisk mjst have gone on an adventure, then had a reason to become Sans, and all of that, right?

So, let's look at how things went originally, before anything was altered by Sans.

...Gaster's experiment WORKS. Monsters ARE eliminated. So Frisk falls, to find NO monsters. So they haven't killed anyone, and are simply trapped in a barren wasteland.

Oh wait, the Brrier broke from his experiment, that was the whole point. So Frisk isn't trapped at all. They have no reason to "get trapped" at all! They would never turn into Sans!

There you go:Argmentum ad absurdum.