Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-26980570-20160320192450/@comment-27701762-20170320232836

David The Potato wrote: Also for Mabian's comment, Alphys did build Mettaton's body, but maybe he is talking about Mettaton NEO. Now I know what your thinking "ooohhh but if you check Mettaton NEO it says ALPHYS'S greatest creation not Napstablooks!" That is true, however I have seen theories that the one who is narrating the entire game and providing infomation is Chara, Now if this theory is correct then how would Chara know that Napstablook built it? Except saying "well Chara might be wrong, therefore it is Napstablook" is a non sequitur. Firstly, that Chara could be wrong does not entail that Chara is wrong, so that argument has to actually be demonstrated, not asserted. Secondly, at all other points in the game there is only one person who is ever named as being responsible for building Mettaton's body: Alphys. Napstablook never mentions working on it, despite the fact that it would seem really easy to hint at through the dialogue: having Alphys, Mettaton, or Blooky mention it, or have it in Mettaton's diaries, or even just give some hint that Blooky is interested in science and robotics. Thirdly, you say it might be Mettaton NEO, but the NEO form is a version of Mettaton that contains his human eradication features, the features that Alphys originally built Mettaton with to impress Asgore. The "finishing" that needs to be done is for EX, but once again it is all but explicitly stated that Alphys is responsible for building the EX body, since those would be the original blueprints that convinced Mettaton to let Alphys build the body for him.

Additionally, the entire argument is built on a false premise: that the lowercase text represents a different person writing the entries. But nowhere is there actually a suggestion that there are multiple people writing the entries, and that entire theory has been built off of people leaping from a minor difference to a conclusion that is not justified by any actual evidence, and in fact every single shred of evidence points to the exact opposite conclusion.

Ok. so if you are still not convinced read this, trust me im about to blow your mind. "''Dear Diary: Shyren's sister "fell down" recently. It's sad. Without her sister to speak for her... she's become more reclusive than ever. So I reached out to her, and told her... that she, Blooky, and I should all perform together sometime. She seemed to like that idea." ''Think about it. Shyren's sister. AN ALMAGAMATE! How would Happstablook have that knowlage about her? Not only that but she said that Shyren's Sister "fell down" Hmm? She fell down? Or became Lemon Bread. Again HOW DOES SHE/HE KNOW ABOUT LEMON BREAD! Well Napstablook helping out Alphys would explain that PERFECTLY. How? Well to know about the Almalgamates Happstablook would need axcess to the True Lab. Now she does have a connection with Alphys, but Alphys could not be able to even bring herself to tell Undyne. Napstablook on the other hand would probably bring her to the True Lab to help her achieve her dream.

My mind remains unblown. You've mistaken "Shyren's sister" with "Lemon Bread." Lemon Bread is an amalgamate that is made in Alphys's lab from monsters that have fallen down. Meaning that the diary entry came before Shyren's sister was turned into an Amalgamate, and hence before she was sent to the True Lab. Mettaton does not know about Lemon Bread.