Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-26006155-20190617222636/@comment-32182236-20190620195120

So that's your timeline? Is that the timeline that I can attempt to simulate and watch crash in my finale?

I'm not just saying we can't know what happened, I'm saying there is not one possible explanation of what happened. All the paths fail-We can eliminate every single one.

And I can prove there is a Gamma timeline by your theory.

Let's start by assuming your theory really does only have two timelines-The one before Gaster fell, and the one after he fell.

When did Ness and Andonuts first put on their disguise? The Alpha Timeline, or the Beta timeline?

If it's the Alpha Timeline, then why was there no suspicion on just what happened to Ness and Andonuts, and where Sans and Gaster came from? Why has nobody linked the disappearance of these two friends with the appearance of these two friends, and why is nobody suspicious of why the souls of these two humans aren't with Asgore? There should definitely at least be rumours of these two humans still being alive.

Now, you might think we can rule out the Beta timeline just like that:Of course Frisk needs a disguise-The humans are after him! ...But we can't just do that. After the Neutral Pacifist Ending, Toriel comes back, and decrees that humans are friends, not enemies. Frisk could live peacefully, with no need for a monster disguise, only needing it when they go back in time.

...But if it is the Beta Timeline, then that means his initial fall must also be in the Beta Timeline. So his new fall, in 201X, therefore must exist in the Gamma Timeline.

If you have a better explanation that keeps the timeline number at two, I'd love to hear it. ;)