Thread:BlackfootFerret/@comment-32182236-20190319173036/@comment-32182236-20190324174630

"Hold on now, when does Gerson say that Asgore was the First Boss Monster?"

He doesn't. I was talking about him being the first KING. Asgore is the king, and Gerson proves he was the first. (King) And if he's the first KING, then Kanashi would have had to have died BEFORE the Kingdom of Monsters ever existed, because if it was formed AFTER they died, Kanashi would be the first king, not Asgore.

But, I suppose you could argue that Kanashi was the first queen instead, and after she died, Asgore would later go on to marry Toriel... Gerson doesn't give us any evidence that this isn't what happened..

---

"What's to keep a monster from coming across one of these, scooping up the power-up, and not telling anyone about it?"

This is actually exactly what I argue Kanashi probably did. Then the humans noticed the power-up themselves, and... well, the rest is history.

"Kanashi might have been a high profile case that people knew about. But there's no prove Kanashi was the first time humans and monsters crossed."

Just because they weren't the first doesn't mean they didn't still commit a crime. We're not supposed to only punish the first person to commit a specific crime.

If you're trying to do this to bring back the co-conspiring idea, do note that if the humans already knew about the ability, they would have declared war far earlier than Kanashi.