Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-26006155-20190403163405/@comment-32182236-20190420013947

Person does have a good point.. In their latest post.

But as for the former one, not so much.

--

Since the Elevator Voice thinks Frisk is Chara, this would also apply retroactively. Just like in Genocide. Here, Flowey reveals he at first didn't recognize us, thought he could take our SOUL, but then, he failed. This means at first, he didn't think Frisk was Chara, but then, after he made that "realization", it happened retroactively. He thinks that Frisk was always Chara. So he'd think that he was talking to Chara back in the Ruins.

The hole in Ferret's "proof" is the fact that the voice never said "It's been a long time since we've talked". Those last three words were added in. Ferret assumed that's what he was talking about, when it could have been something else.