Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-26006155-20190617222636/@comment-32182236-20190629011751

Asriel being alive in Deltarune also makes perfect sense according to my rival theory-That Deltarune is a world where the monsters won the war.

If the monsters won, they were never trapped underground. Which means Chara's plan would have never heeded to happen, so Asriel would never die.

So I ran over it because both possibilties work just fine with it.

Remember Chapter 4, where I did give you credit? Sometimes you do well.. When you actually use strict evidence. But I've seen how many times you simply go with what makes a good story.. What adds meaning to things.

That's not the scientific method. It's not you I'm trying to break.. It's a theory built using the same principles as alchemy.

All I ask is you just use the scientific method, and deductive reasoning. And nothing more than that, besides our friend Occam's Razor.. And that should be used last-After all, we want the simplest explanation... That also accounts for all the evidence.

Accounts for. That means give an explanation for that makes sense. Sometimes three rocks are just three rocks... And if a theory says they are... We can't rule it out by that claim alone. Of course, if it said there were NO rocks at all... That'd be grounds to debunk it.

So, how does the "Deltarune is a different world only loosely connected with Undertale" hold up? Well:

Toriel and Asgore broke up. This was boind to happen eventually, even if the monsters won the war.

Asriel is still alive. No war, no plan, no Chasriel fusion, no death.

Undyne never met Alphys:They met by the garbage dump.

Gerson is dead:Places the real-world time after the time that Undertale happens in

Crystal:Is this Snowdrake's mother? If so, well, she's dead. And not an Amalgamate. I won't claim this busts your theory... Because we're not sure if it's Snowdrake's mother. But my theory has it make sense-No Barrier, no DT experiments, no Amalgamates.

Non-Goner Gaster Followers:This could be the world where Gaster and his followers were sent into, if Deltarune realy is Gaster's Entry 17 Experiment