Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-26006155-20190617222636/@comment-32182236-20190805223701

It's not that the Elevator Voice knows Chara's name.

Analyze my statement for what it actually says. It says that if Gaster knew Frisk, they shouldn't have called Frisk Chara.

It couldn't have been referring to Frisk... Because he literally used Chara's name. Not "Frisk", not "Ness", and not "Varik".

So this isn't a conversation between Gaster and Frisk. Gaster and Chara? Okay, maybe, though I still think it's Flowey and Chara. But Gaster would not have called Frisk using Chara's name.