Talk:W. D. Gaster/@comment-26931958-20160519080014/@comment-26814804-20160519125323

Ok, here's how it went down. It originally had the Gaster card in the deck, which looks like the mysteryman. But it and several other cards were suddenly pulled from the official store a few days after release, without any sufficient explanation.

So, either Gaster isn't the mysteryman, and Toby took it down to make sure there was no confusion later on, when and if his identity is revealed, or Gaster is the mysteryman, and Toby pulled the card to prevent spoilers for when and if his identity is revealed, because he obviously wants Gaster to be mysterious as possible.