Talk:Eight Humans/@comment-73.49.158.165-20151116051747/@comment-23912792-20151120093225

All I can think of is that the shoes are of all sizes and only a couple of humans made their way to Toriel. We know that monster reverse engineer technology whatever human items come from the dump. That means that there are other ways into the underground.

Here's my bet:

The Nerd (Purple Soul) was killed by Gerson since he sells the items.

The Sheriff (Yellow Soul) fell into a river and probably died of Drowning or by his wounds and a monster just happened to find him at the right time since Bratty and Catty claims that they found his items in the dump.

The Aqua soul either was the only one to have stayed with Toriel or was the first human to be murdered since his/her items are found in the ruins.

those are just some of my ideas.