Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-26006155-20190617222636/@comment-32182236-20190625000333

I think I spotted a potential contradiction in Mother 1's narrative. ...But of course, what appears like a contradiction might just be a hint at something else later on.

Here's the "contradiction" I found. I find it strange that I didn't notice it until now, because I wrote down BOTH parts of the contradiction in Part 4 of my analysis, and still didn't spot it!

So, the people of Magicant don't know or care about the outside world. For them, Magicant is all that matters-They scoff at leaving the place, and ask what "outside" even IS. Yet, there's someone there who acts like Ninten's dad, and knows how much money Ninten has... On Earth. The outside world. The world that they supposedly don't know about.

Here's my possible solutions.

1:This person is not from Magicant, but from Earth. This could perhaps hint that many other Magicantians come from Earth as well, and merely only pretend that there's no outside, because Magicant is just far better.

2:Ninten's dad... Is in Magicant. Perhaps one of the humans that we see in the shops there. It'd certainly explain why we don't actually meet him so far. It could even be that this person who acts like Ninten's dad.. IS Ninten's dad.