Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-26006155-20190425222457/@comment-32182236-20190609205746

You think he was eaten?

...We hear a jumpscare, not a chop.

By the way, that sound before the jumpscare? That sound actually happens throughout nearly the entire recording before then. Yet, when Purple Guy gets springtrapped, it happens near instantly. So this can't be a springlock failure we're hearing.

When I said all the evidence, I meant all the evidence, Ferret.

Now, how about I model your model.. And try to explain where it breaks down.

--

I'm not asking how Charlie feels alive. I'm asking how she eats and breathes, and other science facts. If the entire part of the mind is a physical process, then of course one could model it with code.

This is a story for us to theorize, not Mystery Science Theater 3000.. right?

--

Before I get really started, I'd like to point out a few miscallenous problems. First off, if Shadow Freddy and the Puppet are the same person, then why do they act so different? Shouldn't their personalities be identical? I understand their abilities being different, but they should act identical.

Second.. Wait, Shadow Freddy is controlling the friends too? Turning them into the bullies we see? They can control humans? ...Okay, first, whose side is Shadow Freddy on? Second, why not just control the other side to get them killed?

...Mind control is overpowered, if you use it correctly. And clearly, she's willing to use it to further her purposes.. (Presuming that you're right about her controlling these people)

But I'll just keep those plot holes at bay for the rest of my analysis.. That way, we actually have one.

Also, we DO have a reason for Foxy being out of order. Have you looked at him? There's holes in his suit-Exposing pieces of his endoskeleton!

Oh, and you made the exact same mistake that Matpat did. William did not die from a Fredbear jumpscare. William died in FNAF3. We see it happen for ourselves. Seriously, you're supposed to fit in with all the evidence, not most of it!

But let's just ignore ALL of those for right now-Even then, we still have problems!

If Shadow Freddy could kill Henry/William/Whoever died on Night 4.. Then why can't she do the same to Mike? Clearly, you're suggesting that Shadow Freddy knows that the night guard is not an endoskeleton, since you're suggesting they killed him at night. So if she would kill Mike (and she DOES, don't forget about that jumpscare that affects YOU), then why does she just sit and garble, instead of doing it instantly? And if this was a limitation, why was she able to surpass it in William's case?

While you've explained a lot, you failed to get the one contradiction I pointed out. Yellowbear's mechanics for Phone Guy are not the same as the mechanics for Mike.

...As I said, Phone Guy's death... is impossible. And a series filled with plot holes and contradictions is a series that has no solvable story. The theorization factor.. Shrinks, if not goes away entirely, because then anything could potentially be a plot hole.

In a world where everything matters, there can't be contradictions. If we see one, it's supposed to mean we got something wrong. I was able to justify many of Undertale's supposed contradictions, by explaining why they aren't. Like how representing magic to form bullet patterns is not the same thing as using magic to generate a barrier.

But FNAF appears to have a contradiction that just can't be explained. The very rules that govern the animatronics are inconsistent.

To explain this, we'd need FNAF's version of the elusive "quantum gravity". Can you find it?