Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-28517148-20170617115826/@comment-32182236-20171215212327

Well, then how a long dead human whose Soul has shattered, which makes them even more dead, is able to take control over another human?

The same way Flowey does. Just like Flowey, they were awakened due to determination. And their body and essence was buried in the spot Frisk falls in.

''Flowey is neither human nor monster and that allows him to absorb Souls both monsters and humans. Just like Frisk, who's not human and carries Chara's Soul.''

OR, just like CHARA, who's no longer a human and sometimes has control of FRISK'S SOUL.

"also Chara's Soul is Chara themselves. See Asriel's relation when he absorbed human's Soul."

You're not your SOUL. Essence and SOUL are two different things, as proven by Asriel. Chara's SOUL is a red SOUL, not a physical body. All Asriel said was that the two shared control-But you have to consider that Chara's SOUL also contained their determination inside of it-Their will to live. Therefore, since Chara's will was inside Asriel, they had control too. This is proven by Alphys extracting determination from the human SOULS.

"Plot hole, I choose you."

I call cherrypicking. We can't just call stuff plot holes just because they violate our THEORIES. My theory actually explains this potential plot hole-Nobody captured Chara's SOUL because it no longer exists. It shattered just like Frisk's does. Here's another potential "plot hole" that implies they're Soulless-They ask for YOUR SOUL. Not "their" SOUL, but YOURS. A human SOUL. But humans can't absorb human SOULs-So the SOUL exchange should be impossible! Unless.. Chara ISN'T a human...

However, entire Undertale doesn't mention anything about demons except Chara's speech, so no.

Undertale doesn't mention anything about ghosts except Mad Dummy and Napstablook. Also, you have to remember that this is the ONLY time (Except for Flowey, which wasn't common knowledge either) that something was brought back to life with pure determination. (Even in Flowey's case, he had a physical body. Chara's case shows what happens if they don't even have that. They have no physical form until you summon them with EXP and Levels of Violence. Besides, just because it was only mentioned once doesn't mean we should just dismiss it! Chara said they're a demon, so either they're lying, mistaken, or they're a demon. Considering that I've ruled out them being a human, and that they pretty much destroy the world, and possibly the universe, I'm going for the latter of the three.

''one small, yellowish Golem, please. And dress it in blue.''

What about a small, whiteish demon/ghost, dressed in green?

''and they are right. ''

Indeed they are. Stolen right from the eighth human.