Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-33504407-20171031195942/@comment-27136653-20180208212352

Mikeykitty123 wrote: Tsskyx wrote: Zephyr5d wrote: Yandere Mugman wrote: Also, why does everyone think that Chara's SOUL is red? YOU NEVER SEE THEIR SOUL!!

E V E R !

Chara's coffin actually proves Chara's soul is RED. Because RED is the color of DETERMINATION. And Chara is indeed evil.

So stop saying it isn't without any proof of it.

Red has nothing to do with determination actually. It may seem like it, but that's just the confirmation bias. In fact, all humans had determination, so by that logic, determination should have all 7 colors. But we know what color does it really have, yellow: http://nochocolate.tumblr.com/post/157954943241/determination-is-yellow

A problem I have is that Chara's coffin is obviously red. And also, some monsters also have determination and yet their souls are white. But yet determination might as well be red because there is no proof or confirmed evidence that it would be other wise.

Monsters have only miniscule amounts of DT in them. I don't think it would be anywhere near enough to give their souls "color." But what do I know.

As for red being DT, the basic assumption is that it is not. When someone makes a claim, they are obligated to provide supporting evidence, not to ask others to backup their original views. So there really isn't much of a discussion about DT's color, when there are no supporting arguments on either side (the most I can provide is that all humans could save and load). In fact, the only way to know its color is to see it in-game. But that didn't come to happen. All I did was that I provided some materials suggesting that DT is yellow (and not the same shade as the color of justice), and since that's the only strong evidence for DT's color that we have right now, I'll stick to it. Mainly because I'm starting to get tired of always labelling everything as "just speculations." I'd very much like to start making definite conclusions about the game by this point.

As for the player being canon, that is questionable, but I am adamant that Flowey's final speech in the pacifist route where he supposedly speaks to Chara was actually aimed at the player. The reason for this is that from a logical point of view, there's no way that Flowey could have known whether Chara was actually there or not, and that the speech makes more sense when aimed at the player, rather that at Chara.