Talk:Frisk/@comment-14382970-20160102012135/@comment-6328506-20160102215801

I think the red soul being shattered is due to the fact monsters use magical attacks directly against the soul which shatters it. Flowey shatter's Asgore's soul by attacking it, so Frisk can't have it, so perhaps monsters accidently shatter your soul when trying to defeat yo (Undyne want's to capture your soul, not destroy it). It's a good question though. Why does our soul shatter and what does that mean? It can refuse to be broken- is that what it does when it reloads? Does it reform itself at an early point in time?

In the Genocide run, Flowey assuming you have a stolen soul might be due to him assuming that, because it is not Chara's soul (whatever may have happened to that), it must be stolen. How he thinks Chara managed to get a soul is confusing- perhaps he doesn't think it's the physical Chara who's stolen another soul, but rather that Chara has possessed someone the same way he's possessed a flower, hijacking the soul of the person in doing so. Why he doesn't assume this in other runs is uncertain- perhaps while he calls you Chara/Player Name, that's him confusing his own memories and he doesn't even realise what he's doing.

The Chara-Frisk relationship isn't explained in the game. Chara is a very ambigous character, so we can't really say for certain what happened to their soul, what their nature is or so on.