Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-39385741-20200106144455/@comment-26907577-20200106151128

You haven't proven anything here.

Here's what you've said, said another way: Sooooooo.
 * 1) Maybe the red SOUL is the only SOUL with enough Determination to SAVE.
 * maybe (adv) : perhaps, possibly. You have no evidence for this statement. Plus, Flowey has no SOUL, and he can SAVE. SOUL power ≠ Determination. SOUL color? We don't know.
 * 1) Chara was not determined to live.
 * This is in strong opposition of the "red is Determination" theory, since Chara had a red SOUL, and was apparently not determined.
 * 1) The only reason Frisk can Load is their Determination.
 * Yes.
 * 1) "Now we have a pretty good theory."
 * No we don't. Now we have three facts, and zero conclusions.
 * 1) Toriel "often feels like she already knows them."
 * Yes. This is frequently explained as "the other humans could SAVE."
 * 1) But they died.
 * Also correct. Frisk can die, too. Players are just usually more stubborn than that.
 * 1) "Perhaps the humans just, simply, reminded Toriel of Chara."
 * "Perhaps" again. It's about as likely as the alternative.

You have several opinions, 5 facts, and no conclusions. You do not have a theory.