Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-26006155-20181123023529/@comment-35806478-20181130211446

Chapter 2: Chara Stuff

You claim that in the Pacifist Route, Frisk "resists" Chara, but in the Genocide Route, Frisk "gives in" to Chara's killing ways. That...is probably false.

We, the player, control Frisk. More specifically, we control Frisk's SOUL, the very culmination of their being. It thus doesn't make sense for Frisk to "give in" to Chara, because I doubt most people thought to themselves, "Darn, man, I really feel like killing these people! It's just so alluring!" There is no "resistance" going on. It's just Frisk and their actions, with Chara sometimes encouraging kills.

Next, you claim (and this is one of the dumbest things I've ever heard) that Sans doesn't die, and instead jumps through a dimensional portal. Your evidence? He talks to a dead Papyrus. It's called near-death hallucinations, people, this is not that hard to understand. Also, Sans in this fight is kind of an enigma. He bleeds, but then he dies and turns to dust. He gives you EXP but doesn't increase your kill count. Speaking of the kill count, Chara could not have killed Frisk for one simple reason: it never increases. And before you say that it doesn't increase because Chara killed Frisk, keep in mind that Chara's name is on the stats screen. Frisk and Chara share LV, EXP, Armor, Weapons, and Kill Count.

Your final claim is that we, the player, are Chara. But if that's the case, how can Chara directly talk to us like you claim they do? Also, (and this is the new dumbest thing I've ever heard) you claim that Chara stabs the player through the computer screen. This can be easily be proven false by observing that there were no news articles of a game that would kill people when you finished it.

This chapter doesn't have that much evidence in it. It's mostly just you building on top of your previous chapter, which I've already proven false.

End of Chapter 2