Talk:Eight Humans/@comment-27610064-20160116055646/@comment-27610064-20160118220925

Uhm... yes... exactly

Toriel tells him that he is a pathetic Whelp because he waited for SIX kids... he has waited for 5 others, and for us.

I really don't understand where people get the number 8 from.

This whole 8 children thing is just confusing, and it makes no sense that the first human soul disappeared, whie Asriels weak monster soul, created Flowey...

I think that the easiest answer is the right one. There are no 8 kids. The souls that you can see are Chara and the 5 other kids.

The thing you linked says nothing about anyone killing anything. he says "rip 6 times" to something we can't see. Yea, that means Rest In Peace. That's what you say when someone dies, not only when you murder someone.

Chara died, Asriel took the soul, Asriel dies, Asriel soul creates Flowey, Chara soul is collected by Asgore, Asgore thinks "Welp, i already have 1 soul, can as well gather 6 more" Asgore waits for 6 kids (As you and Toriel say) and that's pretty much it.

If your only argument of Charas soul, not being one of the visible souls, is that Chara appears somewhere at some point, there literally everything could have happened. Maybe evil Charas soul was waiting inside the canister that Asgore put it in, because it kept it "alive" and then broke out offscreen? Or maybe part of the soul went into flowey, and part into the canister... That one appereance of Chara is so weird and random, it could even be Gaster in disguise...