Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-28517148-20170617115826/@comment-32182236-20171215230901

"Your entire explanation is based on error. Monsters are different than humans, they are incomparable. There is no such thing as human essence, only monster has essence that allows to bring back Asriel to life as Flowey. To bring back a human you need their Soul in untouched condition and put it in some body. And Asriel's relation proves that Soul is still a person, an aware being (sorry, I can't find better words to describe this) - They were the one that picked up their own empty body."

There's no proof that humans do not have essence. In fact, if we consider what the concept of "essence" is, humans DO have essence. monsters' essense is contained within the dust of their body. Chara's essence was contained within their body... You know, the thing buried under the garden we fell on top of?

"Chara were and still is a human - they has human Soul. They also controls Frisk's body not Soul, but I don't care."

No, they don't, because their SOUL shattered.

"Still based on error."

It's only an error if it contradicts evidence and/or creates those plot holes. Human essence is very plausible, and very likely. If DT is the will to live, and essence is identity.. Chara has an identity too, so they must also have essence, since the two are synonymous. I see no reason to deny that this is the case.

"Your explanation already contains error. I will stay with a plot hole.'

It contains what appears to be an assumption, as humans were never directly stated to have essence. That doesn't make it definitively wrong. Plot holes ARE definitively wrong, though.

"I don't know what's worse - my plot hole or your human essence as attempt to fill that hole."

Your plot hole, because it's a plot hole. Plot holes and contradictions are the two worst things that can ever exist in a theory. So unless human essence creates more plot holes, it's better.

"According to game and you Chara's body has rotted and Soul shattered. There is nothing you can bring back to life."

There is-Their essence. And their body is still there. That's just not what we brought back to life. We called out to their essence specifically, awakening them as a non-physical entity-That's what happens when you have essence and DT, but no body. Take for example, the Mad Dummy-They're a ghost, until they gain a body to possess. Chara's similar. This is how they possess you in the Post-Geno Pacifist Ending.