Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-35615238-20190120203248/@comment-39551791-20191106163812

My only issue with this is the Cyan soul. It would be practically impossible for Cyan to die in the ruins, as Asgore has Cyan's soul. Asgore said that he had no idea where Toriel went, so we can assume he never went to the ruins. It's also implied by the shopkeeper in Snowdin and by Asgore that nobody ahs been able to access the ruins since Toriel went there after Asgore declared war on humans. If Cyan died in the ruins Asgore wouldn't have had all six souls, because the door was locked and nobody ever went there. But besides that I do find your speculation very interesting!