Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-31981697-20170722123329/@comment-27136653-20171015112815

The thing about the game box is, the only counterevidence is the logo. Everything else shows that it must be Undertale. And you can't disprove that the Annoying Dog doesn't represent Toby by using the logo as an argument, since that's already a solid fact. I would rather say that despite the incorrect sprite, the game cannot be anything BUT Undertale. And another fact is, that Toby did some parts explicitly as a joke, so those in particular are the things we should be taking with a grain of salt.

If you choose to interpret everything literally, you will run into contradictions, in which case you must eliminate the side that has less supporting arguments/proof. In the case of the Annoying Dog, it's the logo, versus the entire room. And turning jokes into facts already counts as bending facts, if you haven't realized.