If the protagonist ACTs to Papyrus at the beginning of the fight, his bone attacks slowly scroll across the bottom, sometimes progressively rising in height and sometimes doing the opposite. However, the bones are not high enough to hit the protagonist's SOUL if the SOUL stays in the middle and as a result, are easy to dodge. Papyrus continues using this attack until Spare or FIGHT is chosen. This attack deals 4 damage per hit.
Attacks go in the following order:
A "blue attack" that Sans warned the protagonist about, causing blue-colored bones to scroll across the Bullet Board. After all the blue-colored bones have passed, however, Papyrus turns the protagonist's SOUL blue and sends a small bone across the screen that catches most players off-guard. Papyrus states that this is his attack, and the SOUL remains blue for the rest of the battle. This reveals that Sans was technically misleading the protagonist about the nature of the assault. Blue bones deal 3 damage per hit; the white bone deals 4 damage.
Series of small bones, then a medium-sized bone.
One small bone, three medium-sized bones, and finally three large bones.
A large bone followed by a large bone dangling from the ceiling of the Bullet Board, three small bones, and a medium-sized bone followed by another large bone dangling from the ceiling.
Three large bones followed by a blue bone, followed by a fast-moving small bone coming from the right of the screen rather than the left.
Two bones with a narrow opening to jump through, a large bone dangling from the ceiling coming from the right side, and 8 bones that form a 'hump'.
Two series of 2 bones with a narrow opening to jump through, another two series of 2 bones except that the opening is higher, a blue bone and a large bone coming from the right side. Finally, 2 bones with a narrow opening come from both sides of the screen.
Papyrus continues the battle by attacking the protagonist with series after series of bones scrolling along the bottom of the square, which can be dodged by jumping. His blue-colored bones are used far less often. All of his attacks use bones, similarly to how Sans attacks. They also are slower and less intense versions of Sans's attacks.
Papyrus eventually prepares a special attack; however, a dog steals it, and he continues the battle with an "absolutely normal attack", albeit more difficult. The attack includes the appearance of the dog (3 damage), bones spelling "COOL DUDE", a bone on a skateboard (2 damage), and a large crowd of bones (3 damage per group, 2 for final bone) that can be jumped over to a far higher level than the blue SOUL can usually reach. After surviving this attack, Papyrus decides to spare the protagonist.
Surviving all of Papyrus's attacks and finally sparing him ends the battle.
When the protagonist receives fatal damage, the player's HP is set to 1 and Papyrus puts an end to the fight prematurely. If the protagonist loses to him three times, Papyrus grows tired of capturing them and offers to allow them to skip his battle and progress.
In the Genocide Route, Papyrus instantly offers to spare the protagonist. However, a single hit kills him. Sparing him aborts the Genocide Route.
After his "Completely Normal Attack", Papyrus's defense is set to his current HP times negative two. It is possible to attack him without instantly killing him, but the only way to do this is by using the Tough Glove and only confirming the attack once rather than four times.
If Papyrus's HP is low enough, he attempts to use his special attack ahead of when he would normally attempt to use it, most likely to ensure the attack is used at least once during a Neutral Route.
ALLOW ME TO TELL YOU ABOUT SOME COMPLEX FEELINGS.
THE JOY OF FINDING ANOTHER PASTA LOVER.
THE ADMIRATION FOR ANOTHER'S PUZZLE-SOLVING SKILLS.
THE DESIRE TO HAVE A COOL, SMART PERSON THINK YOU ARE COOL.
THESE FEELINGS... THEY MUST BE WHAT YOU ARE FEELING RIGHT NOW!!!
I CAN HARDLY IMAGINE WHAT IT MUST BE LIKE TO FEEL THAT WAY.
AFTER ALL, I AM VERY GREAT.
I DON'T EVER WONDER WHAT HAVING LOTS OF FRIENDS IS LIKE.
I PITY YOU... LONELY HUMAN...
WORRY NOT!!! YOU SHALL BE LONELY NO LONGER!
I, THE GREAT PAPYRUS, WILL BE YOUR... ...
NO... NO, THIS IS ALL WRONG! I CAN'T BE YOUR FRIEND!
THE KING WILL TRIM A HEDGE IN THE SHAPE OF MY SMILE!!!
MY BROTHER WILL ... WELL, HE WON'T CHANGE VERY MUCH.
I'LL HAVE LOTS OF ADMIRERS!! BUT...
WILL ANYONE LIKE ME AS SINCERELY AS YOU?[If flirted with]
HOW WILL I KNOW IF PEOPLE SINCERELY LIKE ME?[If not flirted with]
SOMEONE LIKE YOU IS REALLY RARE...
AND DATING MIGHT BE KIND OF HARD...[If flirted with]
I DON'T THINK THEY'LL LET YOU GO...[If not flirted with]
AFTER YOU'RE CAPTURED AND SENT AWAY.
URGH... WHO CARES! GIVE UP!!
GIVE UP OR FACE MY... SPECIAL ATTACK!!!
YEAH!!! VERY SOON I WILL USE MY SPECIAL ATTACK!
NOT TOO LONG AND I WILL USE THAT SPECIAL ATTACK!!!
THIS IS YOUR LAST CHANCE... BEFORE MY SPECIAL ATTACK!!
BEHOLD...! MY SPECIAL ATTACK!
WHAT THE HECK! THAT'S MY SPECIAL ATTACK! HEY! YOU STUPID DOG! DO YOU HEAR ME!? STOP MUNCHING ON THAT BONE!!! HEY!!! WHAT ARE YOU DOING!!! COME BACK HERE WITH MY SPECIAL ATTACK!!! ... OH WELL. I'LL JUST USE A REALLY COOL REGULAR ATTACK.
"SIGH" HERE'S AN ABSOLUTELY NORMAL ATTACK.
WELL...! 'HUFF' IT'S CLEAR... YOU CAN'T! 'HUFF' DEFEAT ME!!! YEAH!!! I CAN SEE YOU SHAKING IN YOUR BOOTS!!! THEREFORE I, THE GREAT PAPYRUS, ELECT TO GRANT YOU PITY!! I WILL SPARE YOU, HUMAN!!! NOW'S YOUR CHANCE TO ACCEPT MY MERCY.
ALAS, POOR PAPYRUS! WELL, AT LEAST I STILL HAVE MY HEAD![Kill]
W-WELL, THAT'S NOT WHAT I EXPECTED... BUT... ST... STILL! I BELIEVE IN YOU! YOU CAN DO A LITTLE BETTER! EVEN IF YOU DON'T THINK SO! I... I PROMISE...[Kill in Genocide Route]
WOWIE!! YOU DID IT!!! YOU DIDN'T DO A VIOLENCE!!! TO BE HONEST, I WAS A LITTLE AFRAID... BUT YOU'RE ALREADY BECOMING A GREAT PERSON! I'M SO PROUD I COULD CRY!!! ... WAIT, WASN'T I SUPPOSED TO CAPTURE YOU...? WELL, FORGET IT! I JUST WANT YOU TO BE THE BEST PERSON YOU CAN BE. SO LET'S LET BYBONES BE BYBONES. I'LL EVEN TELL YOU HOW TO LEAVE THE UNDERGROUND! JUST KEEP GOING EAST! EVENTUALLY, YOU'LL REACH THE KING'S CASTLE. THEN YOU CAN LEAVE! OH, I ALMOST FORGOT TO TELL YOU... TO REACH THE EXIT, YOU WILL HAVE TO MEET... THE KING.[Spare in Genocide Route; the rest of the dialogue proceeds as normal]
YOU'RE TOO WEAK! I WAS EASILY ABLE TO CAPTURE YOU!!! I WILL NOW SEND YOU TO THE CAPTURE ZONE!! OR, AS SANS CALLS IT... OUR GARAGE??? YOU'RE IN THE DOGHOUSE NOW! NYEH HEH HEH HEH HEH HEH HEH!!![If protagonist is at 1 HP]
WELL!!! YOU MAY HAVE CLEVERLY ESCAPED FROM JAIL BEFORE... BUT THIS TIME, I'VE UPGRADED THE FACILITIES. NOT ONLY WILL YOU BE TRAPPED... BUT YOU WON'T EVEN WANT TO LEAVE!!! NYEH HEH HEH HEH HEH HEH HEH!!![Captured second time]
YOU ARE... PERSISTENT! BUT! IT JUST WON'T WORK ON ME! I AM THE PERSISTENTEST! AND IF YOU THINK YOU ARE PERSISTENESTER... THAT IS WRONG! GRAMMATICALLY WRONG! BECAUSE THE CORRECT FORM WOULD BE... NOT AS PERSISTENTEST AS PAPYRUS, THE PERSISTENTESTEST! I HOPE YOU ENJOYED THIS LESSON. NYEH HEH HEH HEH HEH HEH HEH!!![Captured third time]
NYOO HOO HOO...
I CAN'T EVEN STOP SOMEONE AS WEAK AS YOU...
UNDYNE'S GOING TO BE DISAPPOINTED IN ME.
I'LL NEVER JOIN THE ROYAL GUARD... AND...
MY FRIEND QUANTITY WILL REMAIN STAGNANT!
REALLY!? YOU WANT TO BE FRIENDS, WITH ME??? WELL THEN... I GUESS... I GUESS I CAN MAKE AN ALLOWANCE FOR YOU![Let's be friends]
HUH? WHY WOULD YOU... BERATE YOURSELF SO LOUDLY??? IS IT BECAUSE... YOU DON'T THINK YOU'RE GOOD ENOUGH TO BE MY FRIEND? NO!!! YOU'RE GREAT!!! I'LL BE YOUR FRIEND![What a loser]
WOW!!! I HAVE FRIENDS!!! AND WHO KNEW THAT ALL I NEEDED TO MAKE THEM...[If not flirted with]
WOWIE!! WE HAVEN'T EVEN HAD OUR FIRST DATE... AND I'VE ALREADY MANAGED TO HIT THE FRIEND ZONE!! WHO KNEW THAT ALL I NEEDED TO MAKE PALS...[If flirted with]
WAS TO GIVE PEOPLE AWFUL PUZZLES AND THEN FIGHT THEM??
YOU TAUGHT ME A LOT, HUMAN.
I HEREBY GRANT YOU PERMISSION TO PASS THROUGH!
AND I'LL GIVE YOU DIRECTIONS TO THE SURFACE.
CONTINUE FORWARD UNTIL YOU REACH THE END OF THE CAVERN.
THEN... WHEN YOU REACH THE CAPITAL, CROSS THE BARRIER.
THAT'S THE MAGICAL SEAL TRAPPING US ALL UNDERGROUND.
ANYTHING CAN ENTER THROUGH IT, BUT NOTHING CAN EXIT...
... EXCEPT SOMEONE WITH A POWERFUL SOUL.
... LIKE YOU!!!
THAT'S WHY THE KING WANTS TO ACQUIRE A HUMAN.
HE WANTS TO OPEN THE BARRIER WITH SOUL POWER.
THEN US MONSTERS CAN RETURN TO THE SURFACE!
OH, I ALMOST FORGOT TO TELL YOU...
TO REACH THE EXIT, YOU WILL HAVE TO PASS...
THROUGH THE KING'S CASTLE.
THE KING OF ALL MONSTERS...
HE'S A BIG FUZZY PUSHOVER!!!
EVERYBODY LOVES THAT GUY.
I AM CERTAIN IF YOU JUST SAY...
"EXCUSE ME, MR. DREEMURR... CAN I PLEASE GO HOME?"
HE'LL GUIDE YOU RIGHT TO THE BARRIER HIMSELF!
ANYWAY!!! THAT'S ENOUGH TALKING!!!
I'LL BE AT HOME BEING A COOL FRIEND!
FEEL FREE TO COME BY AND HANG OUT!!![If not flirted with]
FEEL FREE TO COME BY AND HAVE THAT DATE![If flirted with]
NYEH HEH HEH HEH HEH HEH HEH!!!
He likes to say: "Nyeh heh heh!"[Check]
Forgettable.[Check on Genocide Route]
Papyrus blocks the way![Encounter]
You're blue now.[After Papyrus's blue attack]
Papyrus is trying hard to play it cool.[Neutral]
Papyrus whispers "Nyeh heh heh!"[Neutral]
Papyrus is preparing a bone attack.[Neutral]
Papyrus is cackling.[Neutral]
Papyrus prepares a non-bone attack then spends a minute fixing his mistake.[Neutral]
Papyrus is rattling his bones.[Neutral]
Smells like bones.[Neutral]
Papyrus remembered a bad joke Sans told and is frowning.[Neutral]
Papyrus is considering his options.[Neutral]
Papyrus is thinking about what to wear for his date.[If flirted with]
Papyrus is thinking about what to cook for his date.[If flirted with]
Papyrus dabs some Bone Cologne behind his ear.[If flirted with]
Papyrus dabs marinara sauce behind his ear.[If flirted with]
Papyrus dabs MTT-Brand Bishie Cream behind his ear.[If flirted with]
Papyrus dabs MTT-Brand Anime Powder behind his ear.[If flirted with]
Papyrus dabs MTT-Brand Cute Juice behind his ear.[If flirted with]
Papyrus dabs MTT-Brand Attraction Slime behind his ear.[If flirted with]
Papyrus dabs MTT-Brand Beauty Yogurt behind his ear.[If flirted with]
Papyrus realizes he doesn't have ears.[If flirted with]
You INSULT, but to no avail. Seems ACTing won't escalate this battle...[Insult #4+ before Papyrus turns the SOUL blue]
Papyrus is too busy FIGHTing to accept your insult.[Insult after Papyrus turns the SOUL blue]
You FLIRT, but to no avail. Seems ACTing won't escalate this battle...[Flirt #3+ before Papyrus turns the SOUL blue]
Papyrus is too busy FIGHTing to flirt back.[Flirt after Papyrus turns the SOUL blue]
You throw the stick. Papyrus brings it back in his mouth.[Using Stick]
Papyrus is getting ready for a regular attack.[After Papyrus's failed special attack]
Papyrus is sparing you.[After Papyrus's completely normal attack/Genocide]
Upon killing Papyrus by cutting off his head, he says "Alas, poor Papyrus!" This is likely a reference to Shakespeare's Hamlet, of the famous scene where Hamlet talks to the skull and says "Alas, poor Yorick!"
If the protagonist loses to Papyrus, Asgore’s sound bite plays as the screen fades to black.